Endovascular thrombectomy for acute ischaemic stroke with established large infarct (TENSION): 12-month outcomes of a multicentre, open-label, randomised trial

Götz Thomalla(Universität Hamburg), Jens Fiehler(Universität Hamburg), Fabien Subtil(Université Claude Bernard Lyon 1), Susanne Bonekamp(Heidelberg University), Anne Hege Aamodt(Oslo University Hospital), Blanca Fuentes(Hospital La Paz Institute for Health Research), Elke R. Gizewski(Innsbruck Medical University), Michael D. Hill(University of Calgary), Antonı́n Krajina(Charles University), Laurent Pierot(Centre Hospitalier Universitaire de Reims), Claus Z. Simonsen(Aarhus University Hospital), Kamil Zeleňák(Comenius University Bratislava), Rolf Ankerlund Blauenfeldt(Aarhus University Hospital), Bastian Cheng(Universität Hamburg), Angélique Denis(Université Claude Bernard Lyon 1), Hannes Deutschmann(Medical University of Graz), Franziska Dorn(University Hospital Bonn), Fabian Flottmann(Universität Hamburg), Susanne Gellißen(Universität Hamburg), Johannes Gerber(University Hospital Carl Gustav Carus), Mayank Goyal(University of Calgary), Jozef Haring(University of Trnava), Christian Herweh(Heidelberg University), Silke Hopf-Jensen(DIAKO), Vi Tuan Hua(Centre Hospitalier Universitaire de Reims), Märit Jensen(Universität Hamburg), Andreas Kastrup(Klinikum Bremen-Mitte), C Keil(Goethe University Frankfurt), Andrej Klepanec(University of Trnava), Egon Kurča(Comenius University Bratislava), Ronni Mikkelsen(Aarhus University Hospital), Markus Möhlenbruch(Heidelberg University), Stefan Müller‐Hülsbeck(DIAKO), Nico Münnich(Witten/Herdecke University), Paolo Pagano(Centre Hospitalier Universitaire de Reims), Panagiotis Papanagiotou(National and Kapodistrian University of Athens), Gabor C. Petzold(University Hospital Bonn), Mirko Pham(Universitätsklinikum Würzburg), Volker Puetz(University Hospital Carl Gustav Carus), Jan Raupach(Charles University), Gernot Reimann(Witten/Herdecke University), Peter Ringleb(Heidelberg University), Maximilian Schell(Universität Hamburg), Eckhard Schlemm(Universität Hamburg), Silvia Schönenberger(Heidelberg University), Bjørn Tennøe(Oslo University Hospital), Christian Ulfert(Heidelberg University), Kateřina Vališ(Masaryk University), Eva Vítková(Charles University), Dominik F. Vollherbst(Heidelberg University), Wolfgang Wick(Heidelberg University), Martin Bendszus(Heidelberg University), Anne Hege Aamodt(Oslo University Hospital), Olaf Adamczewski, Kirill Alektoror, März Alexander, Maria Eleni Alexandrou, Quentin Alias, Fadha Elawi Al-Kuzae, Julien Allard, Rahman Al-Schameri, Alberto Álvarez, Grethe Andersen, Rolf AnkerlundBlaufeldt(Aarhus University Hospital), Riedel Antje, Hannes Appelbohm(Klinik und Poliklinik für Psychotherapie und Psychosomatik), Maria Argren, Anne Assmann(Klinik und Poliklinik für Psychotherapie und Psychosomatik), Michael Augustin(University of Calgary), E Bach(Innsbruck Medical University), Michal Bar, Maria Barleben, Flore Baronnet, Andrés Barrios, Xénia Bavúzová, Rikke BayThomsen, Sandra Becker, Sylvia Beer, Daniel Behme, Maximilian Bellut(Universität Hamburg), Martin Bendszus(Heidelberg University), Joachim Berkefeld, Maximillian Bester, Felix J. Bode, Christian Boehme(Heidelberg University), Ramona Boese, Ferdinand O. Bohmann, Susanne Bonekamp(Heidelberg University), Jan Borggrefe(Charles University), Erendira Gabriela Boss, Maria Boutchakova, Elfi Boxhammer, Annemarie Brandhofe, Michael O. Breckwoldt(University of Calgary), Casper Brekenfeld, Alex Brehm, Christian Brem(Heidelberg University), Stella Breuer, Tobias Breyer, Petra Brodová, Gabriel Broocks, Christoph Brosinski, Nele Bubel, Jiří Búřil, Martin Čábal(Heidelberg University), Laura Casado, Elena de Celis(Comenius University Bratislava), Emmanuel Chabert, Daniel Charissé, Bastian Cheng(Universität Hamburg), Vendelı́n Chovanec, Peter Cidlinsky(Heidelberg University), Juraj Cisár, Frédéric Clarençon, Sophie Crozier, Nina Čurdová, Michele Damaskinos, Dorte Damgaard, Martin Daniš(Heidelberg University), Florian Dazinger, Milani Deb‐Chatterji, Asima Delalic, Agnieszka Delekta, Stephen Delorme, Hannes Deutschmann(Medical University of Graz), Elie Diamandis, Tove Diedrichsen, Irena Doležalová, Franziska Dorn(University Hospital Bonn), Franziska Dorn(University Hospital Bonn), Richard du Mesnil de Rochemont, Kristina DupontHougaard, Taraneh Ebrahimi, Florian Eff, Ilona Eliášová, Brian Enriquez, Mostafa Ergawy, Fabian Essig(Universität Hamburg), Maiken Falkesgaard, Simon Fandler-Höfler(Aarhus University Hospital), Andrés Fernández, Jean‐Christophe Ferré, Anna Ferrier, Jens Fiehler(Universität Hamburg), Krystian Figlewski, Sebastian Fischer, Urs Fischer, Fabian Flottmann(Universität Hamburg), Robert Forbrig, Christian Förch(Heidelberg University), Annette Fromm, Blanca Fuentes(Hospital La Paz Institute for Health Research), Ines Gaedke, Romana Galczak, Malik Galijašević, Bernhard Ganser, Thomas Gattringer, Matthias Gawlitza, Sarah Gelhard, Susanne Gellißen(Universität Hamburg), Johannes Gerber(University Hospital Carl Gustav Carus), Michail Panagiotis Giannakakis, Karin Gindlhuber, Elke R. Gizewski(Innsbruck Medical University), Bernhard Glodny, Tim Godel, Einar Goebell, David Goldemund, Michael Görtler(University of Calgary), Mayank Goyal(University of Calgary), Astrid Grams, Joachim Gruber, Katharina Gruber, Thomas Günthner‐Lengsfeld, Kathrin Haase, Floriana Hacker-Ivan, Erika Hallerstig, Christian Hametner(Heidelberg University), Uta Hanning, Jozef Haring(University of Trnava), Michal Haršány, Ján Haršány(Charles University), Christian Hartmann(Heidelberg University), Eva Hassler, Kristina Hauptmann, Karl Georg Hæusler, Constantin Hecker, Victoria Hellstern, Hans Henkes, Victoria Hernández, Christian Herweh(Heidelberg University), Tim Hilgenfeld, Michael D. Hill(University of Calgary), Niels Hjort, Nina HjortJensen, Maya Hoelter(University of Calgary), Karl‐Titus Hoffmann, Brigitte Holst, Markus Holtmannspoetter(Heidelberg University), Silke Hopf-Jensen(DIAKO), Julia Hoppe, Susanne Hörner(Universität Hamburg), Leif HougaardSoerensen, Vi Tuan Hua(Centre Hospitalier Universitaire de Reims), Alexander Hubert, Eva Hurtíková(Charles University), Stanislava Jakubíček, Tanja Janjic, Kirsten Jaramillo, Angela Jedlitschka, Schiela Jensen(Universität Hamburg), Märit Jensen(Universität Hamburg), Jessica Jesser, Leonie Jestaedt, Sabine Johnson, Tomáš Jonszta, P. Kalmár(Heidelberg University), Sanja Karabegovic, Kollo Karen, Andreas Kastrup(Klinikum Bremen-Mitte), Hopp Katja, Natalia Keeba, Petra Keese, Christina Kefaloykos, Fee Keil(Goethe University Frankfurt), Lars Kellert, Christoph Kellinghaus, Roxane‐Isabelle Kestner, Stefan Kiechl(DIAKO), Monika Killer‐Oberpfalzer, Andrej Klepanec(University of Trnava), Casjupea Knispel, Michael Knoflach(University of Calgary), Sabine Köhler, Konstantin Kohlhase, Alexander M. Kollikowski, Martin Kovář(Heidelberg University), Antonı́n Krajina(Charles University), Michael Kral(University of Calgary), Georgi Krastev, Lars Udo Krause, Rudolf Kreidenhuber, Tomáš Křivka, Adam Krkoška, Jan Robert Kröger, Moritz Kronlage, Paweł Krukowski, Julia Kühn, Egon Kurča(Comenius University Bratislava), Natalia Kurka, Michael Kuschnerow(University of Calgary), Rita Lachmund, Susanne Lamprecht(Universität Hamburg), Rüdiger Lange, Monika Lauer, Alonso de Leciñana, Sara Leder, Anne Léger(Klinik und Poliklinik für Psychotherapie und Psychosomatik), Nils Lehnen, Dominik Lehrieder(Heidelberg University), Maximilian Leißner(Universität Hamburg), Markus Leitinger(Heidelberg University), Ursula Leitner, Stéphanie Lenck, Eva Lenzenweger(Charles University), Thomas Liebig, Stephan Lowens, Manuel Lunzer, Christian Maegerlein(Heidelberg University), Marton Magyar, Leonardo Marques, David Matyáš, Gabriele Maurer, Matthias Mauritz, Thormann Maximilian(Universität Hamburg), Lukas Mayer-Süß, Stephan Meckel, Oldřich Medek, Julius N. Meißner, Pavel Mencl, Andrea Merkle(Klinikum Bremen-Mitte), Birte Mesche, Dominik Michalski(Heidelberg University), Robert Mikulík, Boris Modrau, Markus Möhlenbruch(Heidelberg University), Alexander Mohr, Christoph Mönninghoff, Tobias Moser, Ramona Mücke, Stefan Müller‐Hülsbeck(DIAKO), Erasmia Broussalis, Sebastian Mutzenbach, Pedro Navía, Ulf Neuberger(Heidelberg University), Hermann Neugebauer, Jens Neumann(Universität Hamburg), Anh Nguyên(Centre Hospitalier Universitaire de Reims), Kurt Niederkorn, Vladimír Nosáľ, Richard Novobilský, Nikos Ntoulias, Lukas Nussbaum, Joanna Oder, Andreas Oldag(Klinikum Bremen-Mitte), Marián Ondrejkovič, Ferdinand Otto, Dagmar Otto, Daniel Paech, Paolo Pagano(Centre Hospitalier Universitaire de Reims), Lars‐Peder Pallesen, Michal Panský, Panagiotis Papanagiotou(National and Kapodistrian University of Athens), Samp Patrick, Harald Paukisch, Johann Pelz(Klinik und Poliklinik für Psychotherapie und Psychosomatik), Inga Petersen, Martina Petersen, Gabor C. Petzold(University Hospital Bonn), Johannes Pfaff(Klinik und Poliklinik für Psychotherapie und Psychosomatik), Johannes Pfaff(Klinik und Poliklinik für Psychotherapie und Psychosomatik), Waltraud Pfeilschifter, Mirko Pham(Universitätsklinikum Würzburg), Alexander Pichler, Laurent Pierot(Centre Hospitalier Universitaire de Reims), Slaven Pikija, Jan PlougmannPovlsen(Charles University), Christoph Polkowski, Nenad Polomac, Rupert Horst Portugaller, Marika Poulsen, Michael Preiß(University of Calgary), Kévin Premat, Sjur Prestsæter, Rocío Prieto‐Pérez, Marios Psychogios, Volker Puetz(University Hospital Carl Gustav Carus), Jan Purrucker(Charles University), Heike Rai, Maximilian Rauch(Universität Hamburg), Jan Raupach(Charles University), Gernot Reimann(Witten/Herdecke University), G. Reimann(Witten/Herdecke University), Sarah C. Reitz, Ondřej Renc, Jasmin Retzlaff, Ricardo Rigual, Peter Ringleb(Heidelberg University), Carlota Rivera-Bengoa, Jorge Rodríguez, Stefan Rohde(DIAKO), Siegfried Rohler, Charlotte Rosso, Christian Roth(Heidelberg University), Thomas Röttcher, Martin Roubec(Heidelberg University), Milada Roztočilová, Svetlana Rudnicka, Gerardo Ruiz, Stephen Ryan, Karla J. Ryckborst, Simen Sandvik, Jan-Hendrik Schäfer, Martin Schaller(Heidelberg University), Maximillian Schell(Universität Hamburg), Peter D. Schellinger(Heidelberg University), Eckhard Schlemm(Universität Hamburg), Florian Schmid, C. G. Schmidt, Marie Louise Schmitz, Claus Schneider(Aarhus University Hospital), Jan‐Erik Scholtz, Silvia Schönenberger(Heidelberg University), Andreas Schröter(Klinikum Bremen-Mitte), Dániel Schwarz, Stephan Schwarz, Daniel Schwarzenhofer, Thomas Seifert‐Held, Alexander Seiler, Fatih Şeker, Eimad Shotar, Claus Z. Simonsen(Aarhus University Hospital), Maria Theresa Simonsen(Aarhus University Hospital), Jozef Sivák(University of Trnava), Karolina Skagen, Mona Skjelland, Alena Šnajdrová, Lazlo Solymosi, Jesper Sømark, Michael Sonnberger(University of Calgary), Jakub Soršák, Nader Sourour, Jogrim Søyland, Daniel Spitzer, Peter B. Sporns(Heidelberg University), Michael Städt(University of Calgary), Eike Steidl, Anne Margrethe Kaalaas Størdal, Sebastian Stösser, Sarah Strickmann, Ondřej Strýček, Igor Suškevič, Ján Sýkora(Charles University), Bjørn Tennøe(Oslo University Hospital), Daniela Thaler, Sara Theisen, Götz Thomalla(Universität Hamburg), Petar Trendafilov, Johannes Trenkler(Klinik und Poliklinik für Psychotherapie und Psychosomatik), Christoph Trumm, Ioannis Tsogkas, Jon‐Anders Tunold, Lars Tveit, Christian Ulfert(Heidelberg University), Kateřina Vališ(Masaryk University), Jiří Vaníček, Christine Vassilev, Eva Vítková(Charles University), Heinz-Leonhard Voit-Höhne, Bohuslav Vojtíšek, Karoline Volderauer, Dominik F. Vollherbst(Heidelberg University), Christoph Vollmuth, Kamila Volna, Ondřej Volný, Poul VonWeitzel-Mudersbach, Martin Vorčák(Heidelberg University), Marlies Wagner, Gaute Kjellevold Wathle, Werner Weber, Anushe Weber, Viktor Weiss, Johannes Weller, Katharina Wenger-Alakmeh, Cyrill Weyland, Friedrich Weymayr, Ulrike Wießpeiner, Johannes Willeit(Klinik und Poliklinik für Psychotherapie und Psychosomatik), Aymeric Wittwer, Frank A. Wollenweber, Ginette Wortmann, Silke Wunderlich(DIAKO), Yanyan Xiong, Se-Jong You, Lasse ZachoSpeiser, Mahtab Zamani, Kamil Zeleňák(Comenius University Bratislava), Jana Zeleňáková, Seraphine Zubel
The Lancet Neurology
July 27, 2024
Cited by 63Open Access
Full Text

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Long-term data showing the benefits of endovascular thrombectomy for stroke with large infarct are scarce. The TENSION trial showed the safety and efficacy of endovascular thrombectomy in patients with ischaemic stroke and large infarct at 90 days. We aimed to investigate the safety and efficacy at 12 months of endovascular thrombectomy in patients who were enrolled in the TENSION trial. METHODS: TENSION was an open-label, blinded endpoint, randomised trial done at 40 hospitals across Europe and one hospital in Canada. We included patients (aged ≥18 years) with acute ischaemic stroke due to large vessel occlusion in the anterior circulation and who had a large infarct, as indicated by an Alberta Stroke Program Early Computed Tomographic Score (ASPECTS) of 3-5 on standard-of-care stroke imaging. We randomly assigned patients (1:1) to receive either endovascular thrombectomy with medical treatment or medical treatment only up to 12 h from stroke onset. The primary outcome was functional outcome across the entire range of the modified Rankin Scale at 90 days. Here, we report the prespecified 12-month follow-up analyses for functional outcome (using the simplified modified Rankin Scale questionnaire), quality of life (using the Patient-Reported Outcomes Measurement Information System 10-item [PROMIS-10] and EQ-5D questionnaires), post-stroke anxiety and depression (using the Patient Health Questionnaire-4 [PHQ-4]), and overall survival. Outcomes (except survival) were assessed in the intention-to-treat population; the survival analysis was based on treatment received. This trial is registered with ClinicalTrials.gov, NCT03094715, and is completed. FINDINGS: We enrolled patients between July 17, 2018, and Feb 21, 2023, when the trial was stopped early for efficacy. 253 patients were randomly assigned, 125 (49%) to endovascular thrombectomy and 128 (51%) to medical treatment only. Median follow-up was 8·36 months (IQR 0·02-12·00). Endovascular thrombectomy was associated with a shift in the distribution of scores on the modified Rankin Scale towards better functional outcome at 12 months (adjusted common odds ratio 2·39 [95% CI 1·47-3·90]). Endovascular thrombectomy was also associated with a better quality of life compared with medical treatment only, as reflected by median scores on the EQ-5D questionnaire index (0·7 [IQR 0·4-0·9] vs 0·4 [0·2-0·7]), median scores for health status on the EQ-5D questionnaire visual analogue scale (50 [IQR 35-70] vs 30 [5-60]), and median global physical health scores on the PROMIS-10 questionnaire (T-score 39·8 [IQR 37·4-50·8] vs 37·4 [32·4-44·9]); although there was not enough evidence to suggest a difference between groups in global mental health scores on PROMIS-10 (41·1 [IQR 36·3-48·3] vs 38·8 [31·3-44·7]) or the numbers of patients reporting anxiety (13 [22%] of 58 vs 15 [42%] of 36) and depression (18 [31%] vs 18 [50%]) on PHQ-4. Overall survival was slightly better in the endovascular thrombectomy group compared with medical treatment only (adjusted hazard ratio 0·70 [95% CI 0·50-0·99]). INTERPRETATION: In patients with acute ischaemic stroke from large vessel occlusion with established large infarct, compared with medical treatment only, endovascular thrombectomy was associated at 12 months after stroke with better functional outcome, quality of life, and overall survival. These findings suggest that the benefits of endovascular thrombectomy in patients with an ischaemic stroke and a large infarct are sustained in the long term and support the use of endovascular thrombectomy in these patients. FUNDING: European Union Horizon 2020 Research and Innovation Programme.


Related Papers

No related papers found

Powered by citation graph analysis