Johannes J. Mager

BACKGROUND: HHT is an autosomal dominant disease with an estimated prevalence of at least 1/5000 which can frequently be complicated by the presence of clinically significant arteriovenous malformations in the brain, lung, gastrointestinal tract and liver. HHT is under-diagnosed and families may be unaware of the available screening and treatment, leading to unnecessary stroke and life-threatening hemorrhage in children and adults. OBJECTIVE: The goal of this international HHT guidelines process was to develop evidence-informed consensus guidelines regarding the diagnosis of HHT and the prevention of HHT-related complications and treatment of symptomatic disease. METHODS: The overall guidelines process was developed using the AGREE framework, using a systematic search strategy and literature retrieval with incorporation of expert evidence in a structured consensus process where published literature was lacking. The Guidelines Working Group included experts (clinical and genetic) from eleven countries, in all aspects of HHT, guidelines methodologists, health care workers, health care administrators, HHT clinic staff, medical trainees, patient advocacy representatives and patients with HHT. The Working Group determined clinically relevant questions during the pre-conference process. The literature search was conducted using the OVID MEDLINE database, from 1966 to October 2006. The Working Group subsequently convened at the Guidelines Conference to partake in a structured consensus process using the evidence tables generated from the systematic searches. RESULTS: The outcome of the conference was the generation of 33 recommendations for the diagnosis and management of HHT, with at least 80% agreement amongst the expert panel for 30 of the 33 recommendations.

DESCRIPTION: Hereditary hemorrhagic telangiectasia (HHT) is an autosomal dominant disease with an estimated prevalence of 1 in 5000 that is characterized by the presence of vascular malformations (VMs). These result in chronic bleeding, acute hemorrhage, and complications from shunting through VMs. The goal of the Second International HHT Guidelines process was to develop evidence-based consensus guidelines for the management and prevention of HHT-related symptoms and complications. METHODS: The guidelines were developed using the AGREE II (Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation II) framework and GRADE (Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation) methodology. The guidelines expert panel included expert physicians (clinical and genetic) in HHT from 15 countries, guidelines methodologists, health care workers, health care administrators, patient advocacy representatives, and persons with HHT. During the preconference process, the expert panel generated clinically relevant questions in 6 priority topic areas. A systematic literature search was done in June 2019, and articles meeting a priori criteria were included to generate evidence tables, which were used as the basis for recommendation development. The expert panel subsequently convened during a guidelines conference to conduct a structured consensus process, during which recommendations reaching at least 80% consensus were discussed and approved. RECOMMENDATIONS: The expert panel generated and approved 6 new recommendations for each of the following 6 priority topic areas: epistaxis, gastrointestinal bleeding, anemia and iron deficiency, liver VMs, pediatric care, and pregnancy and delivery (36 total). The recommendations highlight new evidence in existing topics from the first International HHT Guidelines and provide guidance in 3 new areas: anemia, pediatrics, and pregnancy and delivery. These recommendations should facilitate implementation of key components of HHT care into clinical practice.

OBJECT: Hereditary hemorrhagic telangiectasia (HHT) is a rare autosomal-dominant vascular dysplasia with a high prevalence of cerebrovascular malformations (CVMs), mostly manifested as arteriovenous malformations (AVMs). The natural history and bleeding risk of these CVMs is unknown. The authors investigated the risk of bleeding in conjunction with clinical and radiological features in patients with HHT and proven CVMs. METHODS: Intravenous digital subtraction (DS) angiography was used to screen 196 patients with HHT for the presence of CVMs. Patients with abnormal results on DS angiography were asked to undergo a conventional cerebral angiographic study. All patients with a proven CVM were assessed by a neurologist. The bleeding risk was retrospectively and prospectively calculated for patients with AVMs only, as well as for the whole cohort of patients with CVMs. Twenty-four patients (12.2%; 16 female and eight male), aged 14 to 66 years (mean 35.4 years) with one or more CVMs were identified. Fifteen patients (62.5%) had a CVM and a pulmonary AVM. Eleven patients (45.8%) exhibited no neurological signs of their CVM; six (25%) had headache or migraine; four (16.7%) had seizures; and three (12.5%) had an intracranial hemorrhage. Twenty-two patients had at least one AVM (with a total of 28 AVMs), whereas two patients only had telangiectases. Twenty-seven AVMs were small (96%), 36% were located in eloquent areas of the brain, and 82% had superficial venous drainage. One third of the patients had multiple CVMs. The bleeding risk for patients with at least one AVM ranged from 0.41 to 0.72% per year, and for the whole cohort the range was 0.38 to 0.69% per year. Calculation of the bleeding risk as determined by lesion-years ranged from 0.36 to 0.56% per year for patients with AVMs and from 0.27 to 0.46% per year for all patients with CVMs. CONCLUSIONS: Patients with HHT have a high risk of harboring a CVM, especially in the presence of a pulmonary AVM. These CVMs are mostly low-grade AVMs (Spetzler-Martin Grade I or II), are frequently multiple, and have a lower risk of bleeding than that associated with sporadic AVMs. Female patients are more often affected than male patients. The inherent low sensitivity of DS angiography screening for CVMs may yield false negative results.