Daniel H. Clarke

Two patients with collagen vascular disease (rheumatoid arthritis and scleroderma) had extremely poor cosmetic results after breast radiation therapy (RT). The patient with rheumatoid arthritis received 5251 cGy at 210 cGy per day, followed by a 1600 cGy iridium-192 implant boost. Between 8 and 11 months post-RT she had severe breast fibrosis, retraction, and pain that required a mastectomy for relief. The patient with scleroderma received 5040 cGy at 180 cGy per day without a boost. Between 1 and 4 months post-RT the systemic symptoms of scleroderma progressed and the breast became hard and retracted. Both rheumatoid arthritis and scleroderma are chronic systemic diseases characterized by severe inflammation and an autoimmune component. The presence of scleroderma at or before treatment should be considered a contraindication to breast RT, whereas the presence of active rheumatoid arthritis should be considered a relative contraindication. An autoimmune mechanism will be presented to explain both the fibrosis and the systemic progression of collagen vascular disease that was observed.

Seventy-four patients with carcinoma of the breast were treated by irradiation without a mastectomy at Stanford between May 1973 and March 1980. Seventy-six breasts were treated because two patients had bilateral simultaneous cancers. Breast edema was noted in 41% of these cases. Analysis of potential predisposing factors revealed that this complication occurred primarily in patients who received a staging axillary lymph node dissection. Lymphedema occurred in 26 of 33 breasts (79%) in patients who had staging axillary dissections; this complication developed in only three of 12 (25%) with axillary samplings and two of 31 (6%) with no axillary surgery. Two groups of patients were identified: (1) 28 patients whose breast edema occurred early (prior to or during radiation therapy), and (2) three patients with late onset edema that developed several months postirradiation. The early edema, which is clearly related to axillary lymph node dissection, gradually improved during the follow-up period with complete or near complete resolution expected by three years. Late onset edema was rare, appears to be related to an axillary radiation dose greater than 5500 rad, and may be irreversible. There was no correlation of breast edema with tumor stage, radiation time/dose factors, the use of bolus, patient weight, or breast size.

Twenty-eight patients with squamous carcinomas of the base tongue were seen and evaluated in a conjoint Head and Neck Tumor Board at Stanford between 1976 and 1982. Fourteen patients were treated by combined external beam and interstitial irradiation, 11 of whom had Stage III and IV carcinomas (American Joint Committee). An initial dose of 5000 to 5500 rad was first delivered by external beam irradiation in 5 to 5.5 weeks, followed approximately 3 weeks later by an iridium 192 (192Ir) interstitial implant boost by the trocar and loop technique. The key to successful treatment of these neoplasms was found to be the use of a lateral percutaneous cervical technique, which placed horizontal loops through the oropharyngeal wall above and below the hyoid bone; the superior loop included the pharyngoepiglottic fold and the tonsilloglossal groove. Standard multiple loop implants (submentally inserted) of the base tongue from the vallecula anteriorly to the circumvallate papillae were also used routinely. This approach has been successful, since 10 of the 14 patients (71%) remain without evidence of disease (mean follow-up, 32 months). There have been only two local recurrences, both on the pharyngoepiglottic fold in patients who did not receive the now standard pharyngoepiglottic fold/lateral pharyngeal wall implants. No patients have relapsed after 18 months. The other 14 patients were treated prospectively during the same period by combining initial resection, radical neck dissection, and postoperative irradiation. In this group, there were more locoregional failures compared to the group treated with radiation therapy alone (5 tongue recurrences and 7 neck relapses); in addition, more severe complications were noted in these 14 patients who received surgery and postoperative irradiation. The authors believe that combined external beam and interstitial irradiation is effective treatment for base tongue carcinomas, especially when the high-dose distribution includes the adjacent tonsilloglossal groove, pharyngoepiglottic fold, and oropharyngeal wall to and below the level of the hyoid bone, in addition to treating an adequate base tongue volume.