Chris McKinnell

Abstract Disorders of testicular function may have their origins in fetal or early life as a result of abnormal development or proliferation of Sertoli cells. Failure of Sertoli cells to mature, with consequent inability to express functions capable of supporting spermatogenesis, is a prime example. In a similar way, failure of Sertoli cells to proliferate normally at the appropriate period in life will result in reduced production of spermatozoa in adulthood. This review focuses on the control of proliferation of Sertoli cells and functional maturation, and is motivated by concerns about 'testicular dysgenesis syndrome' in humans, a collection of common disorders (testicular germ-cell cancer, cryptorchidism, hypospadias and low sperm counts) which are hypothesized to have a common origin in fetal life and to reflect abnormal function of Sertoli (and Leydig) cells. The timing of proliferation of Sertoli cells in different species is reviewed, and the factors that govern the conversion of an immature, proliferating Sertoli cell to a mature, non-proliferating cell are discussed. Protein markers of maturity and immaturity of Sertoli cells in various species are reviewed and their usefulness in studies of human testicular pathology are discussed. These markers include anti-Mullerian hormone, aromatase, cytokeratin-18, GATA-1, laminin alpha5, M2A antigen, p27(kip1), sulphated glycoprotein 2, androgen receptor and Wilms' tumour gene. A scheme is presented for characterization of Sertoli-cell only tubules in the adult testis according to whether or not there is inherent failure of maturation of Sertoli cells or in which the Sertoli cells have matured but there is absence, or acquired loss, of germ cells. Functional 'de-differentiation' of Sertoli cells is considered. It is concluded that there is considerable evidence to indicate that disorders of maturation of Sertoli cells may be a common underlying cause of human male reproductive disorders that manifest at various life stages. This recognition emphasizes the important role that animal models must play to enable identification of the mechanisms via which failure of proliferation and maturation of Sertoli cells can arise, as this failure probably occurs in fetal life.

This study investigated whether neonatal exposure of male rats to estrogenic compounds altered pubertal spermatogenesis (days 18 and 25) and whether the changes observed resulted in long-term changes in testis size, mating, or fertility (days 90-100). Rats were treated neonatally with a range of doses (0.01-10 microg) of diethylstilbestrol (DES; administered on alternate days from days 2-12), a high dose of octylphenol (OP; 2 mg administered daily from days 2-12) or bisphenol A (Bis-A; 0.5 mg administered daily from days 2-12), or vehicle, while maintained on a standard soy-containing diet. The effect on the same parameters of rearing control animals on a soy-free diet was also assessed as was the effect of administering such animals genistein (4 mg/kg/day daily from days 2-18). Testis weight, seminiferous tubule lumen formation, the germ cell apoptotic index (apoptotic/viable germ cell nuclear volume), and spermatocyte nuclear volume per unit Sertoli cell nuclear volume were used to characterize pubertal spermatogenesis. Compared with (soy-fed) controls, DES administration caused dose-dependent retardation of pubertal spermatogenesis on day 18, as evidenced by decreases in testis weight, lumen formation, and spermatocyte nuclear volume per unit Sertoli cell and elevation of the germ cell apoptotic index. However, the two lowest doses of DES (0.1 and 0.01 microg) significantly increased spermatocyte nuclear volume per unit Sertoli cell. Similarly, treatment with either OP or Bis-A significantly advanced this and some of the other aspects of pubertal spermatogenesis. Maintenance of control animals on a soy-free diet also significantly advanced lumen formation and spermatocyte nuclear volume per unit Sertoli cell compared with controls fed a soy-containing diet. Administration of genistein reversed the stimulatory effects of a soy-free diet and significantly retarded most measures of pubertal spermatogenesis. In general, plasma FSH levels in the treatment groups changed in parallel to the spermatogenic changes (reduced when pubertal spermatogenesis retarded, increased when pubertal spermatogenesis advanced). By day 25, although the changes in FSH levels largely persisted, all of the stimulatory effects on spermatogenesis seen on day 18 in the various treatment groups were no longer evident. In adulthood, testis weight was decreased dose dependently in rats treated neonatally with DES, but only the lowest dose group (0.01 microg) showed evidence of mating (3 of 6) and normal fertility (3 litters). Animals treated neonatally with OP or Bis-A had normal or increased (Bis-A) testis weights and exhibited reasonably normal mating/fertility. Animals fed a soy-free diet had significantly larger testes than controls fed a soy-containing diet, and this difference was confirmed in a much larger study of more than 24 litters, which also showed a significant decrease in plasma FSH levels and a significant increase in body weight in the males kept on a soy-free diet. Neonatal treatment with genistein did not alter adult testis weight, and although most males exhibited normal mating and fertility, a minority did not mate or were infertile. It is concluded that 1) neonatal exposure of rats to low levels of estrogens can advance the first wave of spermatogenesis at puberty, although it is unclear whether this is due to direct effects of the estrogen or to associated elevation of FSH levels; 2) the effect of high doses of OP and Bis-A on these processes is essentially benign; and 3) the presence or absence of soy or genistein in the diet has significant short-term (pubertal spermatogenesis) and long-term (body weight, testis size, FSH levels, and possibly mating) effects on males.

This study aimed to identify the mechanism(s) for impairment of spermatogenesis in adulthood in rats treated neonatally with estrogens. Rats were treated (days 2-12) with 10, 1, or 0.1 microg diethylstilbestrol (DES), 10 microg ethinyl estradiol (EE), 10 mg/kg of a GnRH antagonist (GnRHa), or vehicle and killed in adulthood. DES/EE caused dose-dependent reductions in testis weight, total germ cell volume per testis, and Sertoli cell volume per testis. Sertoli cell number at 18 days of age in DES-treated rats was reduced dose dependently. GnRHa treatment caused changes in these parameters similar to those in rats treated with 10 microg DES. Plasma FSH levels were elevated (P < 0.001) to similar levels in all treatment groups regardless of differences in Sertoli cell number and levels of inhibin B; the latter reflected Sertoli cell number, but levels were disproportionately reduced in animals treated with high doses of DES/EE. Neonatal estrogen treatment, but not GnRHa, caused dose-dependent reductions (40-80%) in plasma testosterone levels in adulthood, but did not alter LH levels. Preliminary evidence suggests that the decrease in testosterone levels in estrogen-treated rats is not due to reduced Leydig cell volume per testis. GnRHa-treated rats exhibited a significant increase in germ cell volume per Sertoli cell and a reduction in germ cell apoptosis, probably because of the raised FSH levels. Despite similar raised FSH levels, rats treated with DES (10 or 1 microg) or EE (10 microg) had reduced germ cell volume/Sertoli cell and increased germ cell apoptosis, especially when compared with GnRHa-treated animals. The latter changes were associated with an increase in lumen size per testis, indicative of impaired fluid resorption from the efferent ducts, resulting in fluid accumulation in the testis. Rats treated neonatally with 0.1 microg DES showed reduced germ cell apoptosis comparable to that in GnRHa-treated animals. The changes in apoptotic rate among treatment groups occurred across all stages of the spermatogenic cycle. It is concluded that 1) neonatal estrogen treatment results in dose-dependent alterations in Sertoli cell numbers, germ cell volume, efficiency of spermatogenesis, and germ cell apoptosis in adulthood; 2) the relatively poor spermatogenesis in estrogen-treated animals is most likely due to altered testis fluid dynamics and/or altered Sertoli cell function; 3) as indicated by FSH (LH) and testosterone levels, the hypothalamic-pituitary axis and Leydig cells are probably more sensitive than the Sertoli cells to reprogramming by estrogens neonatally; and 4) elevated FSH levels in adulthood may improve the efficiency of spermatogenesis.

Fetal exposure of male rats to di (n-butyl) phthalate (DBP) induces testicular changes remarkably similar to testicular dysgenesis syndrome in humans; these include induction of focal areas of dysgenetic tubules in otherwise normal testes. In searching for the fetal origins of the latter, we used image analysis to show that exposure to 500 mg/kg DBP [embryonic day (E)13.5-20.5)] caused abnormal aggregation of Leydig cells centrally in the fetal testis. This aggregation was not due to increase in Leydig cell number, and Leydig cell size was significantly reduced in DBP-exposed animals, as were testosterone levels and immunoexpression of P450 side-chain cleavage enzyme. The Leydig cell aggregates did not exhibit evidence of focal proliferation at E17.5-19.5. Using confocal microscopy and Leydig (3beta-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase) and Sertoli (anti-Mullerian hormone) cell-specific markers, we show that fetal Leydig cell aggregates in DBP-exposed animals trap isolated Sertoli cells within them at E21.5. These areas of intermingled cells are still apparent on postnatal d 4, after cessation of DBP treatment, when they may form misshapen seminiferous cords that trap (intratubular) Leydig cells within them. These centrally located dysgenetic tubules contain germ cells in early puberty, but by adulthood they are Sertoli cell only, implying that presence of intratubular Leydig cells interferes with spermatogenesis. It is concluded that DBP-induced fetal Leydig cell aggregation may be a key event in formation of focal dysgenetic areas in the testis, and identification of the mechanisms underlying these events may give new insights into the fetal origins of testicular dysgenesis syndrome disorders in the human.

Diethylstilbestrol (DES) was administered neonatally (Days 2-12; 10 microg on alternate days) to rats, and developmental changes in Sertoli cell function were evaluated at 18, 25, and 35 days of age and compared to those observed in rats administered a GnRH antagonist (GnRHa; Days 2 and 5; 10 mg/kg) or a vehicle (controls). DES and GnRHa treatments resulted in similar reductions in both Sertoli cell numbers (40% for DES, 48% for GnRHa) and suppression of testicular growth at 18 and 25 days, though by 35 days the suppression was more pronounced (p < 0.001) in DES-treated animals. Plasma FSH levels were suppressed markedly at 18 and 25 days, but not at 35 days, in GnRHa-treated rats, whereas in DES-treated rats the FSH levels were suppressed significantly only at 35 days. Both treatments suppressed plasma levels of inhibin B, though this was more pronounced (p < 0.05) in DES- than in GnRHa-treated rats. In controls, Sertoli cell immunoexpression of inhibin alpha, sulfated glycoprotein-1 (SGP-1), and androgen receptor (AR) increased in intensity and changed to an adult, stage-dependent pattern by 25 days. In GnRHa-treated rats these changes were reduced in intensity but were similar to those in controls at 35 days. In DES-treated rats, the increase in intensity and stage-dependent pattern of immunoexpression of inhibin alpha, SGP-1, and AR were virtually absent at 25 days but were present by 35 days. Germ cell volume per Sertoli cell was reduced in GnRHa- and DES-treated rats compared with controls at 18 and 25 days but was significantly greater (p < 0. 001) in DES- than in GnRHa-treated rats at 35 days. The proportion of apoptotic to viable germ cells was increased (p < 0.01) in GnRHa- and DES-treated rats compared with controls at 18 and 25 days; but at 35 days, values in GnRHa-treated rats had declined to control values whereas those for DES-treated rats remained 10-fold elevated (p < 0.001). In adulthood, testis weight and daily sperm production were reduced by 43% and 44%, respectively, in GnRHa-treated rats, but spermatogenesis was grossly normal. Comparable changes were observed in approximately 25% of DES-treated rats, but the majority exhibited > 60% reduction in testis weight with many Sertoli cell-only tubules and very low daily sperm production. Taken together, these data are interpreted as providing evidence for direct modulation of Sertoli cell (maturational) development by DES.