Large DNA deletions occur during DNA repair at 20-fold lower frequency for base editors and prime editors than for Cas9 nucleases

Abstract

When used to edit genomes, Cas9 nucleases produce targeted double-strand breaks in DNA. Subsequent DNA-repair pathways can induce large genomic deletions (larger than 100 bp), which constrains the applicability of genome editing. Here we show that Cas9-mediated double-strand breaks induce large deletions at varying frequencies in cancer cell lines, human embryonic stem cells and human primary T cells, and that most deletions are produced by two repair pathways: end resection and DNA-polymerase theta-mediated end joining. These findings required the optimization of long-range amplicon sequencing, the development of a k-mer alignment algorithm for the simultaneous analysis of large DNA deletions and small DNA alterations, and the use of CRISPR-interference screening. Despite leveraging mutated Cas9 nickases that produce single-strand breaks, base editors and prime editors also generated large deletions, yet at approximately 20-fold lower frequency than Cas9. We provide strategies for the mitigation of such deletions. DNA repair after Cas9-mediated double-strand breaks induces large DNA deletions at frequencies 20-fold higher than elicited by base editors and prime editors leveraging Cas9 nickases producing single-strand breaks.