Landiolol and Organ Failure in Patients With Septic Shock

Tony Whitehouse(University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust), Md. Anower Hossain(University of Warwick), Gavin D. Perkins(University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust), Anthony Gordon(Imperial College London), Julian Bion(University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust), Duncan Young(University of Oxford), Danny McAuley(Queen's University Belfast), Mervyn Singer(University College London), Janet M. Lord(University of Birmingham), Simon Gates(Cancer Research UK Clinical Trials Unit), Tonny Veenith(University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust), Niall MacCallum(University College London Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust), Joyce Yeung(University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust), Richard Innes(Musgrove Park Hospital), Ingeborg Welters(University of Liverpool), Nafisa Boota(University of Warwick), Emma Skilton(University of Warwick), Belinder Ghuman(University of Warwick), Maddy Hill(University of Warwick), Scott Regan(University of Warwick), Dipesh Mistry(University of Warwick), Ranjit Lall(University of Warwick), STRESS-L Collaborators(University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust), Tonny Veenith(University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust), Jaimin Patel, Nick Murphy, Mansoor N. Bangash, Tomasz Torliński, Nicholas Talbot, Catherine Snelson, Dhruv Parekh, Amisha Desai, Mary Kotada, Yin May Chin, Sophie Holden, Aoife Neal, Maximina Ventura, Martin Pope, Samantha Harkett, Christopher McGhee(University of Warwick), Emma Fellows, Amy Bamford, Ronald Carrera, Karen Ellis, Elaine Spruce, Liesl Despy, Stephanie Porter, Colin Bergin, Stephanie Gouny, Hazel Smith, Tracy Mason, Natalie Dooley, Amy Clark(University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust), Joyce Yeung(University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust), Jo Gresty, Teresa Melody, Ellie Reeves, Rachel Smith(University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust), Julia Sampson, ACCP Team BHH Critical Care Unit, Chris Nutt, James P. McNamee(Queen's University Belfast), Danny Mcauley(Queen's University Belfast), Anen Boyle, Loren McGinley, Chris Wright, Kathryn Ward, Lauren Macartney, Justine McCann, Brian Wells, Janette Mills, Leona Bannon, Aisling O’Neill, Stephanie Finn(Imperial College London), Anthony Gordon(Imperial College London), David Antcliffe, Stephen J. Brett, Dorota Banach, Leilani Cabreros, Laura Curran, Sonia Sousa Arias, Roceld Rojo, Ziortza Fernández de Pinedo Artaraz, Phoebe Coghlan, Maie Templeton, A. Elhaddad, Zohonon Sabine Loko, Gareth J. Barker(University College London Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust), Niall MacCallum(University College London Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust), David Brealey(University College London), Mervyn Singer(University College London), Kristian Warnes, Nina Bason, Dorota Filipowicz, Georgia Bercades, Ingrid Hass, Jung Hee Ryu, Deborah Smyth, Dorothy Ilano(Queen's University Belfast), Daniel Harvey, Louise Conner, Lucy Ryan, Cecilia Peters, Megan Meredith, Megan K. McAulay, Zoe Whitman, Lucy Morris, C Woodford, Sally Hodgkinson, Sonya Finucane, Luigi Camporota, Manu Shankar‐Hari, Marlies Ostermann, Aneta Bociek, Rosario Lim, Neus GrauNovellas, Natalie Palmer, Angela Cape, Anea Kelly, Gill Arbane, Sarah Campos, Michael J. Singh, Jinny Yoo(Musgrove Park Hospital), Richard Innes(Musgrove Park Hospital), Fiona C. Dempsey, Patricia Doble, Rebecca Purnell, Moira Tait(University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust), J. Hutter, Corinne Pawley(University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust), Joy Rowe, Catherine Wane(Musgrove Park Hospital), Richard Burgess, Ashly Thomas, Pulak Paul(University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust), Brenda White, Wayne Lovegrove, Mandy Gill, Lynne Wade, Tracy Brear, Vishal Dhokia, Debbie Jackson, Sarah Shelton, Jill Kirk, Anew Boulton, Alistair Roy(Imperial College London), Anthony Rostron, Zeynep Elcioglu, Lindsey Woods, Sarah Cornell, Rebecca Betts, Jill Holden, Stephen Laybourne, Kimberley Rogerson, Jeremy Bewley, Rebekah Johnson, Anna Chillingworth, Bethany Gumbrill, Hilary Galvin, Kim Wright, Georgia Efford, Kathleen Corcoran, Libby Cole, Katie Sweet, Denise Webster, Lisa Grimmer, Gemma Paris, Chloe Searles, Zoe Garland, Charly Gibson, Melanie Hutchings, Fiona Walters, Sinéad Kelly, Lorraine Scaife, Kelly Littlewood, James Leavy, Shirley Todd(Imperial College London), Elizabeth Gordón, Sadie Heddon, Victor Mariano, Karin Gupwell, Rebecca Appelboam, Samantha Keenan, Cassie Brady(University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust), Ian Mew(Nuffield Orthopaedic Centre), Duncan Chambler, Sarah Williams, Pauline Ashcroft, Patricia Williams, James Rees, Sophie Wiseman, Sarah Horton, Mark Shortland, Stephanie Dukes, Andy Ball, Michael Z. Spivey, Jennie Stephens, Sarah Bean, Karen Burt, Rachel Chapman, Carol Richards, Lorraine Moore, Linda Allsop, Amber Wynn, Louise Latty, Sam Waddy, Kayleigh Spencer, Bethan Stowe, Georgina Cox, Helen McMillan, Liana Lankester, Colin Wells, Rosalyn Squire, Mike Marner, Robert J. Jackson, Nikitas Nikitas, Stuart Dickson, Henrik Reschreiter, James Bromilow, James Keegan, Chris Loew, Ken Power, Spike Briggs, Julie Camsooksai, Sarah Patch, Sarah M. Jenkins, Sharon Power, Elizabeth Woodward, David Pogson, Zoe Daly, Steve Rose, Aimi Collins, Amy L. Phelps, Helen Claridge, Christine Minnis, Sarah K. Inglis, Lutece Brimfield, Charlotte Wong(University of Liverpool), Ingeborg Welters(University of Liverpool), Karen Williams, Victoria Waugh, Julie Patrick-Heselton, Emily Johnson, David M. Shaw, Brian Johnston, Maryam Crews, Alicia Waite, Vinoth Sankar, Jonathan R. Walker, Peter Turton(Musgrove Park Hospital), Richard Wenstone, Jaime Fernandez Roman, Alison Hall, Maria Lopez Martinez, David Hamilton, David Coey, Philip Shelley, Martin Goulding, K. L. Kavanagh(Queen's University Belfast), Ann Marron, Hannah Allsop, Philip Hopkins, John Smith, Harriet Noble, Evita Pappa, Clare Finney, Sinead Heyler(University of Warwick), Emma Clarey, Maeve Cockrell, Maria Depante, Kevin O’Reilly, Christopher C. M. Waterhouse, Vicky Chu(Imperial College London), Joanne Gordon, Greg Marchant, Stuart Chandler, Senait Haile, Joanna Flanagan, Gaynor Notcheva, Dom Jimenez, Dilbagh Gill, Sunil Jamadarkhana, Sunita Gohil, Sura Dabbagh, Katy-Jane Chick, Carina Cruz, Vikram Anumakonda, Vanessa Moore, Lisa Stanton, Sharon Westwood, Jacqueline Smith, Karen Reid(University of Warwick), R Gidda, Elena Anastasescu, Karim M. Salem, Mohamed Mooradun, Michael Reay, Nasirul Ekbal, Margaret McNeil, Helder Filipe, Aarti Nandani, Glykeria Pakou, Mark de Neef, Sara Mingo, Amitaa Maharajh, Prashanth Nandhabalan, Thomas Billyard, Laura Wild, Pamela Bremmer, Geraldine Ward, Fiona McGurk, Rajbinder Deol, Catherine Morgan, Kirandeep Pachoo, Barbara Phillips, Owen Boyd, Claire Phillips, Rakhee Hindocha, Stephen Age, John B. Porter, Alexander Harrison, Lynn Evans, Louise Ortiz-Ruiz de Gordoa, Dominika Wlazly, Tomas Anews, Jess West, Ben Attwood, P. Jefferson, Penny Parsons, Sophie Mason, Bridget Campbell(University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust), Julia Jones, Kathryn Webb, Karen Spicer, Angela Day, Camilla Stagg, Noor Ayesha Shah(University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust), Ian Purcell, Lucy Shafiq, Coralie Carle, Rebecca Chilvers, Heather MacColl, Alan Pope, Anew Holder, Nicola Butterworth‐Cowin, Matthew Davies, Louise Wilmer, Nadeem Ismail, Sneha Gurung, Piers Murphy, Toby Elkington, Matthew Camilleri, Rob Charnock, Claire Shevlin(University of Warwick), Emma McGregor, Chris Clarke, Judith Hinds, Sophie Hughes, Raymond McKee, Denise McFarland, Roisin McNulty, A. R. Breen, Elizabeth Wilby, Nora Youngs(Musgrove Park Hospital), Richard French, Suzie Colquhoun, Claire Posnett, Clare Howcroft, A. Fowler Taylor(Cancer Research UK Clinical Trials Unit), Simon Whiteley, Bethan Ogg, Kate Long, Alicia Tomkinson(University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust), I Clement', Tara Lal Shrestha, Leigh Dunn, Verity Calder, Maite Babio-Galan, Kimberley Zwiggelaar, Anne Mitchell, Julie Stephenson, Lesley Rigden, Jude Davison, J. W. S. Carter, Kate Howard, Hazel Cahill(University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust), Lia Grainger, Poppy Cottrell-Howe, Abigail Rowbotham, Laura Jeffery, Emily Waterman, Arran Fletcher, Zoe Guy, Isabel Birkinshaw(University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust), J Ingham(University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust), Zoë Scott, Samantha Stead, Raha West, Pradeep Shanmugasundaram, Judith Abrams, Geraldine Hambrook, Katarina Manso(University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust), Sally Scott, Iram Husain, Evelyn Chan, Siobhan Gettings, Anil Hormis, Rachel Walker, Dawn Collier, Cheryl Graham, Victoria Murray, Katy Curtis, Charlotte Widdop, Sarah Kimpton, Susan H. Oakley, Zirlish Afzal, James Varley, Petra Polgarova, Andrew Johnston, Lynne Whitehead, Andrew Conway Morris, Razeen Mahroof, Sofia Teixeira, Nazrudeen Ali, Jonny Wilkinson, Alex Lyon, Charlotte Mills, Kathryn Hall, Gayna Grantham, Lorraine Campey, Helen Cronshaw, Livia Malanjum, Lucy Dudgeon, Clare Hinchley, Stephen Langhon(University of Birmingham), Jane Hosea, Anea Hillyer, Rachel Kontogonis, Oninye Ndefo, Laura Robinson(University College London Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust), Callum Kaye(Cancer Research UK Clinical Trials Unit), Kevin Sim(University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust), Ian Scott(University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust), Teresa Scott, Felicity Anderson, Wendy Mitchell, P Cooper, James MacBrayne, Fiona Willox, Kate Richmond, Rebecca Colleron, Erin Trumper, Bartosz Was, Michael Christie, Amber E. Johnson, Gillian Price(Cancer Research UK Clinical Trials Unit), Malcolm Sim, Robert Docking(University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust), Scott McQueen, Sophie Kennedy-Kay, Lynn Abel, Steven Henderson, Kirsty McLeash, Anew Gratrix, Victoria Martinson, Louise Foster, Elizabeth Stones, Vicki Lowthorpe, Daniel Crawley, Susannah Leaver, Sarah Farnell Ward, Romina Pepermans Saluzzio, Frances Robinson, Carlos Delgado, Geraldine Gray, Rebecca Kanu, Robert S. Oakley, Karen M. Keates, Timothy Walsh
JAMA
October 25, 2023
Cited by 90Open Access
Full Text

Abstract

Importance: Patients with septic shock undergo adrenergic stress, which affects cardiac, immune, inflammatory, and metabolic pathways. β-Blockade may attenuate the adverse effects of catecholamine exposure and has been associated with reduced mortality. Objectives: To assess the efficacy and safety of landiolol in patients with tachycardia and established septic shock requiring prolonged (>24 hours) vasopressor support. Design, Setting, and Participants: An open-label, multicenter, randomized trial involving 126 adults (≥18 years) with tachycardia (heart rate ≥95/min) and established septic shock treated for at least 24 hours with continuous norepinephrine (≥0.1 μg/kg/min) in 40 UK National Health Service intensive care units. The trial ran from April 2018 to December 2021, with early termination in December 2021 due to a signal of possible harm. Intervention: Sixty-three patients were randomized to receive standard care and 63 to receive landiolol infusion. Main Outcomes and Measures: The primary outcome was the mean Sequential Organ Failure Assessment (SOFA) score from randomization through 14 days. Secondary outcomes included mortality at days 28 and 90 and the number of adverse events in each group. Results: The trial was stopped prematurely on the advice of the independent data monitoring committee because it was unlikely to demonstrate benefit and because of possible harm. Of a planned 340 participants, 126 (37%) were enrolled (mean age, 55.6 years [95% CI, 52.7 to 58.5 years]; 58.7% male). The mean (SD) SOFA score in the landiolol group was 8.8 (3.9) compared with 8.1 (3.2) in the standard care group (mean difference [MD], 0.75 [95% CI, -0.49 to 2.0]; P = .24). Mortality at day 28 after randomization in the landiolol group was 37.1% (23 of 62) and 25.4% (16 of 63) in the standard care group (absolute difference, 11.7% [95% CI, -4.4% to 27.8%]; P = .16). Mortality at day 90 after randomization was 43.5% (27 of 62) in the landiolol group and 28.6% (18 of 63) in the standard care group (absolute difference, 15% [95% CI, -1.7% to 31.6%]; P = .08). There were no differences in the number of patients having at least one adverse event. Conclusion and Relevance: Among patients with septic shock with tachycardia and treated with norepinephrine for more than 24 hours, an infusion of landiolol did not reduce organ failure measured by the SOFA score over 14 days from randomization. These results do not support the use of landiolol for managing tachycardia among patients treated with norepinephrine for established septic shock. Trial Registration: EU Clinical Trials Register Eudra CT: 2017-001785-14; isrctn.org Identifier: ISRCTN12600919.


Related Papers

No related papers found

Powered by citation graph analysis