The evolution of non-small cell lung cancer metastases in TRACERx

Maise Al Bakir(The Francis Crick Institute), Ariana Huebner(The Francis Crick Institute), Carlos Martínez‐Ruiz(Cancer Research UK), Kristiana Grigoriadis(The Francis Crick Institute), Thomas B.K. Watkins(The Francis Crick Institute), Oriol Pich(The Francis Crick Institute), David A. Moore(The Francis Crick Institute), Selvaraju Veeriah(Cancer Research UK), Sophia Ward(The Francis Crick Institute), Joanne Laycock(Cancer Research UK), Diana Johnson(Cancer Research UK), Andrew Rowan(The Francis Crick Institute), Maryam Razaq(Cancer Research UK), Mita Akther(Cancer Research UK), Cristina Naceur‐Lombardelli(Cancer Research UK), Paulina Prymas(Cancer Research UK), Antonia Toncheva(Cancer Research UK), Sonya Hessey(Cancer Research UK), Michelle Dietzen(The Francis Crick Institute), Emma Colliver(The Francis Crick Institute), Alexander M. Frankell(The Francis Crick Institute), Abigail Bunkum(Cancer Research UK), Emilia L. Lim(The Francis Crick Institute), Takahiro Karasaki(The Francis Crick Institute), Christopher Abbosh(Cancer Research UK), Crispin T. Hiley(The Francis Crick Institute), Mark S. Hill(The Francis Crick Institute), Daniel E. Cook(The Francis Crick Institute), Gareth A. Wilson(The Francis Crick Institute), Roberto Salgado(Peter MacCallum Cancer Centre), Emma Nye(The Francis Crick Institute), Richard Stone(The Francis Crick Institute), Dean A. Fennell(University of Leicester), Gillian Price(University of Aberdeen), Keith M. Kerr(University of Aberdeen), Babu Naidu(University of Birmingham), Gary Middleton(University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust), Yvonne Summers(University of Manchester), Colin R. Lindsay(University of Manchester), Fiona Blackhall(University of Manchester), Judith Cave(University Hospital Southampton NHS Foundation Trust), Kevin G. Blyth(Cancer Research UK Scotland Institute), Arjun Nair(Royal London Hospital), Asia Ahmed(Royal London Hospital), Magali N. Taylor(Royal London Hospital), Alexander James Procter(Royal London Hospital), Mary Falzon(Royal London Hospital), David Lawrence(University College Hospital), Neal Navani(University College Hospital), Ricky M. Thakrar(University College Hospital), Sam M. Janes(University College London), Dionysis Papadatos-Pastos(Royal London Hospital), Martin Förster(Royal London Hospital), Siow Ming Lee(Royal London Hospital), Tanya Ahmad(Royal London Hospital), Sergio A. Quezada(Cancer Research UK), Karl S. Peggs(Royal London Hospital), Peter Van Loo(The University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center), Caroline Dive(Cancer Research UK), Allan Hackshaw(Cancer Research UK), Nicolai J. Birkbak(Aarhus University), Simone Zaccaria(Cancer Research UK), J.F. Lester(Swansea Bay University Health Board), Amrita Bajaj(University Hospitals of Leicester NHS Trust), Apostolos Nakas(University Hospitals of Leicester NHS Trust), Azmina Sodha-Ramdeen(University Hospitals of Leicester NHS Trust), Keng Ang(University Hospitals of Leicester NHS Trust), Mohamad Tufail(University Hospitals of Leicester NHS Trust), Mohammed Fiyaz Chowdhry(University Hospitals of Leicester NHS Trust), Molly Scotland(University Hospitals of Leicester NHS Trust), Rebecca Boyles(University Hospitals of Leicester NHS Trust), Sridhar Rathinam(University Hospitals of Leicester NHS Trust), Claire Wilson(University of Leicester), Domenic Marrone(University of Leicester), Sean Dulloo(University of Leicester), Gurdeep Matharu(University of Leicester), Jacqui Shaw(University of Leicester), Joan Riley(University of Leicester), Lindsay Primrose(University of Leicester), Ekaterini Boleti(Royal Free London NHS Foundation Trust), Heather Cheyne(Aberdeen Royal Infirmary), Mohammed S. Khalil(Aberdeen Royal Infirmary), Shirley Richardson(Aberdeen Royal Infirmary), Tracey Cruickshank(Aberdeen Royal Infirmary), Sarah Benafif(Royal London Hospital), Kayleigh Gilbert(Whittington Hospital), Akshay J. Patel(University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust), Aya Osman(University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust), Christer Lacson(University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust), Gerald Langman(University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust), Helen Shackleford(University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust), Madava Djearaman(University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust), Salma Kadiri(University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust), Angela Leek(Cancer Research UK Manchester Centre), Jack Davies Hodgkinson(Cancer Research UK Manchester Centre), Nicola Totten(Cancer Research UK Manchester Centre), Ángeles Montero(Manchester University NHS Foundation Trust), Elaine Smith(Manchester University NHS Foundation Trust), Eustace Fontaine(Manchester University NHS Foundation Trust), Felice Granato(Manchester University NHS Foundation Trust), Helen Doran(Manchester University NHS Foundation Trust), Juliette Novasio(Manchester University NHS Foundation Trust), Kendadai Rammohan(Manchester University NHS Foundation Trust), Leena Dennis Joseph(Manchester University NHS Foundation Trust), Paul Bishop(Manchester University NHS Foundation Trust), Rajesh Shah(Manchester University NHS Foundation Trust), Stuart Moss(Manchester University NHS Foundation Trust), Vijay Joshi(Manchester University NHS Foundation Trust), Philip Crosbie(Cancer Research UK), Fábio Gomes(The Christie NHS Foundation Trust), Kate Brown(The Christie NHS Foundation Trust), Mathew Carter(The Christie NHS Foundation Trust), Anshuman Chaturvedi(Cancer Research UK), Lynsey Priest(Cancer Research UK), Pedro Oliveira(Cancer Research UK), Matthew Krebs(University of Manchester), Alexandra Clipson(Cancer Research UK), Jonathan Tugwood(Cancer Research UK), Alastair Kerr(Cancer Research UK), Dominic G. Rothwell(Cancer Research UK), Elaine Kilgour(Cancer Research UK), Hugo J.W.L. Aerts(Brigham and Women's Hospital), Roland F. Schwarz(University of Cologne), Tom L. Kaufmann(Max Delbrück Center), Rachel Rosenthal(The Francis Crick Institute), Zoltán Szállási(Semmelweis University), Judit Kisistók(Aarhus University), Mateo Sokač(Aarhus University), Miklós Dióssy(Eötvös Loránd University), Jonas Demeulemeester(The Francis Crick Institute), Aengus Stewart(The Francis Crick Institute), Alastair Magness(The Francis Crick Institute), Angeliki Karamani(London Cancer), Benny Chain(London Cancer), Brittany Campbell(The Francis Crick Institute), Carla Castignani(The Francis Crick Institute), Chris Bailey(The Francis Crick Institute), Clare Puttick(The Francis Crick Institute), Clare E. Weeden(The Francis Crick Institute), Claudia Lee(The Francis Crick Institute), Corentin Richard(Cancer Research UK), David R. Pearce(London Cancer), Despoina Karagianni(London Cancer), Dhruva Biswas(The Francis Crick Institute), Dina Levi(The Francis Crick Institute), Elena Hoxha(London Cancer), Elizabeth Larose Cadieux(The Francis Crick Institute), Eva Grönroos(The Francis Crick Institute), Felip Gálvez-Cancino(London Cancer), Foteini Athanasopoulou(The Francis Crick Institute), Francisco Gimeno-Valiente(Cancer Research UK), George Kassiotis(The Francis Crick Institute), Georgia Stavrou(London Cancer), Gerasimos Mastrokalos(London Cancer), Hao-Ran Zhai(The Francis Crick Institute), Helen L. Lowe(London Cancer), Ignacio Matos(London Cancer), Jacki Goldman(The Francis Crick Institute), James L. Reading(London Cancer), James R. Black(Cancer Research UK), Javier Herrero(London Cancer), Jayant K. Rane(The Francis Crick Institute), Jérôme Nicod(The Francis Crick Institute), Jie Min Lam(Royal London Hospital), John A. Hartley(London Cancer), Katey S.S. Enfield(The Francis Crick Institute), Kayalvizhi Selvaraju(London Cancer), Kerstin Thol(Cancer Research UK), Kevin Litchfield(Cancer Research UK), Kevin W. Ng(The Francis Crick Institute), Kezhong Chen(London Cancer), Krijn K. Dijkstra(The Netherlands Cancer Institute), Krupa Thakkar(Cancer Research UK), Leah Ensell(London Cancer), Mansi Shah(London Cancer), Marcos Vásquez(London Cancer), Maria Litovchenko(London Cancer), Mariana Werner Sunderland(Cancer Research UK), Michelle Leung(The Francis Crick Institute), Mickael Escudero(The Francis Crick Institute), Mihaela Angelova(The Francis Crick Institute), Miljana Tanić(London Cancer), Monica Sivakumar(Cancer Research UK), Nnennaya Kanu(Cancer Research UK), Olga Chervova(London Cancer), Olivia Lucas(The Francis Crick Institute), Othman Al‐Sawaf(The Francis Crick Institute), Philip Hobson(The Francis Crick Institute), Piotr Pawlik(London Cancer), Robert B. Bentham(Cancer Research UK), Robert E. Hynds(London Cancer), Roberto Vendramin(The Francis Crick Institute), Sadegh Saghafinia(Cancer Research UK), Saioa López(London Cancer), Samuel Gamble(London Cancer), Seng Kuong Anakin Ung(London Cancer), Sharon Vanloo(Cancer Research UK), Stefan Boeing(The Francis Crick Institute), Stephan Beck(London Cancer), Supreet Kaur Bola(London Cancer), Tamara Denner(The Francis Crick Institute), Teresa Marafioti(Royal London Hospital), Thanos P. Mourikis(London Cancer), Victoria J. Spanswick(London Cancer), Vittorio Barbè(The Francis Crick Institute), Wei-Ting Lu(The Francis Crick Institute), William Hill(The Francis Crick Institute), Wing Kin Liu(Cancer Research UK), Yin Wu(London Cancer), Yutaka Naito(The Francis Crick Institute), Zoe Ramsden(The Francis Crick Institute), Catarina Veiga(University College London), Gary Royle(London Cancer), Charles‐Antoine Collins‐Fekete(University College London), Francesco Fraioli(University College London), Paul Ashford(Institute of Structural and Molecular Biology), Tristan Clark(University College London), Elaine Borg(Royal London Hospital), James M. Wilson(Royal London Hospital), Davide Patrini(University College Hospital), Emilie Martinoni Hoogenboom(Royal London Hospital), Fleur Monk(Royal London Hospital), James W. Holding(Royal London Hospital), Junaid Choudhary(Royal London Hospital), Kunal Bhakhri(Royal London Hospital), Marco Scarci(Royal London Hospital), Martin Hayward(Royal London Hospital), Nikolaos Panagiotopoulos(Royal London Hospital), Pat Gorman(Royal London Hospital), Reena Khiroya(Royal London Hospital), Robert Stephens(Royal London Hospital), Yien Ning Sophia Wong(Royal London Hospital), Steve Bandula(Royal London Hospital), Abigail Sharp(Cancer Research UK), Sean Smith(Cancer Research UK), Nicole Gower(Cancer Research UK), Harjot Kaur Dhanda(Cancer Research UK), Kitty S. Chan(Cancer Research UK), Camilla Pilotti(Cancer Research UK), Rachel Leslie(Cancer Research UK), Anca Grapa(Institute of Cancer Research), Hanyun Zhang(Institute of Cancer Research), Khalid AbdulJabbar(Institute of Cancer Research), Xiaoxi Pan(Institute of Cancer Research), Yinyin Yuan(The University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center), David Chuter(The Patients Association), Mairead MacKenzie(The Patients Association), Serena Chee(University Hospital Southampton NHS Foundation Trust), Aiman Alzetani(University Hospital Southampton NHS Foundation Trust), Lydia Scarlett(University Hospital Southampton NHS Foundation Trust), Jennifer Richards(University Hospital Southampton NHS Foundation Trust), Papawadee Ingram(University Hospital Southampton NHS Foundation Trust), Silvia Austin(University Hospital Southampton NHS Foundation Trust), Eric Lim(Guy's and St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust), Paulo De Sousa(Guy's and St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust), Simon Jordan(Guy's and St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust), Alexandra Rice(Guy's and St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust), Hilgardt Raubenheimer(Guy's and St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust), Harshil Bhayani(Guy's and St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust), Lyn Ambrose(Guy's and St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust), Anand Devaraj(Guy's and St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust), Hema Chavan(Guy's and St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust), Sofina Begum(Guy's and St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust), Silviu Buderi(Guy's and St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust), Daniel Kaniu(Guy's and St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust), Mpho Malima(Guy's and St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust), Sarah Booth(Guy's and St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust), Andrew G. Nicholson(Guy's and St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust), Nadia Fernandes(Guy's and St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust), Pratibha Shah(Guy's and St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust), Chiara Proli(Guy's and St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust), Madeleine Hewish(University of Surrey), Sarah Danson(Sheffield Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust), Michael Shackcloth(University of Liverpool), Lily Robinson(Princess Alexandra Hospital NHS Trust), Peter Russell(Princess Alexandra Hospital NHS Trust), Craig Dick(NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde), John Le Quesne(NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde), Alan Kirk(Golden Jubilee National Hospital), Mo Asif(Golden Jubilee National Hospital), Rocco Bilancia(Golden Jubilee National Hospital), Nikos Kostoulas(Golden Jubilee National Hospital), Mathew Thomas(Golden Jubilee National Hospital), Mariam Jamal‐Hanjani(University College Hospital), Nicholas McGranahan(Cancer Research UK), Charles Swanton(The Francis Crick Institute)
Nature
April 12, 2023
Cited by 232Open Access
Full Text

Abstract

. We report the longitudinal evolutionary analysis of 126 non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) tumours from 421 prospectively recruited patients in TRACERx who developed metastatic disease, compared with a control cohort of 144 non-metastatic tumours. In 25% of cases, metastases diverged early, before the last clonal sweep in the primary tumour, and early divergence was enriched for patients who were smokers at the time of initial diagnosis. Simulations suggested that early metastatic divergence more frequently occurred at smaller tumour diameters (less than 8 mm). Single-region primary tumour sampling resulted in 83% of late divergence cases being misclassified as early, highlighting the importance of extensive primary tumour sampling. Polyclonal dissemination, which was associated with extrathoracic disease recurrence, was found in 32% of cases. Primary lymph node disease contributed to metastatic relapse in less than 20% of cases, representing a hallmark of metastatic potential rather than a route to subsequent recurrences/disease progression. Metastasis-seeding subclones exhibited subclonal expansions within primary tumours, probably reflecting positive selection. Our findings highlight the importance of selection in metastatic clone evolution within untreated primary tumours, the distinction between monoclonal versus polyclonal seeding in dictating site of recurrence, the limitations of current radiological screening approaches for early diverging tumours and the need to develop strategies to target metastasis-seeding subclones before relapse.


Related Papers

No related papers found

Powered by citation graph analysis