Prehospital transdermal glyceryl trinitrate in patients with ultra-acute presumed stroke (RIGHT-2): an ambulance-based, randomised, sham-controlled, blinded, phase 3 trial

Philip M. Bath(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Polly Scutt(University of Nottingham), Craig S Anderson(University of Nottingham), Jason P. Appleton(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Evind Berge(Oslo University Hospital), Lesley Cala(University of Nottingham), Mark Dixon(University of Nottingham), Timothy M England(University of Nottingham), Peter J. Godolphin(University of Nottingham), Diane Havard(University of Nottingham), Lee J Haywood(University of Nottingham), Trish Hepburn(University of Nottingham), Kailash Krishnan(University of Nottingham), Grant Mair(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Alan Montgomery(University of Nottingham), Keith W. Muir(University of Nottingham), Stephen Phillips(Dalhousie University), Stuart Pocock(University of London), John F. Potter(University of East Anglia), Christopher Price(University of Nottingham), Marc Randall(University of Nottingham), Thompson Robinson(University of Leicester), Christine Roffe(Keele University), Peter M. Rothwell(John Radcliffe Hospital), Else Charlotte Sandset(Oslo University Hospital), Nerses Sanossian(University of Southern California), Jeffrey L. Saver(University of California, Los Angeles), Angela Shone(University of Nottingham), A Niroshan Siriwardena(Oslo University Hospital), Joanna M. Wardlaw(UK Dementia Research Institute), Lisa J Woodhouse(University of Nottingham), G.S. Venables(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Nikola Sprigg(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Pierre Amarenco, Keith W. Muir(University of Nottingham), Shannon Amoils, Malcolm Jarvis, Peter M. Rothwell(John Radcliffe Hospital), Peter Sandercock(John Radcliffe Hospital), Kjell Asplund, Colin Baigent, Sandeep Ankolekar(University of Nottingham), Harriet Howard, Christopher Lysons, Gemma Walker, Hayley Gregory, James N. Kirby, Jennifer Smithson, Joanne Keeling, Nadia Frowd, Robert G. Gray, Richard Dooley, W. Bromley Clarke, Patricia Robinson(University of Leicester), Zhe Kang Law(UK Dementia Research Institute), Sheila Hodgson, Adam Millington, Eleni Sakka, David L. Buchanan, Jeb Palmer, Dominick Shaw(University of Nottingham), Heidi Cobb(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Renae Johnson(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Tanya Payne(Oslo University Hospital), Robert Spaight(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Anne Spaight, M A Sajid(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Amanda Whileman, Elizabeth J. Hall(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), H. Cripps(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), John A Toms(UK Dementia Research Institute), Rachel Gascoyne(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Sylvia Wright(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Martin Cooper(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Andrea Palfreman, Anoja Rajapakse, Inez Wynter(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Kashif Musarrat(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Amit Mistri, Chirag B. Patel(Keele University), Claire Stephens(Keele University), Sher Bahadar Khan(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), S Patras(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Mohamed Soliman(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Abduelbaset Elmarimi, Claire Hewitt(Keele University), Elizabeth Watson(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Ibrahim Wahishi(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Julia Hindle(UK Dementia Research Institute), Leigh Perkin(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Mélissa Wills(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Sally A. Arif(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Simon Leach(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), S Butler(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Dermot O’Kane(University of Nottingham), Colette Smith(Keele University), J O'Callaghan(UK Dementia Research Institute), W Sunman(University of Nottingham), Amanda Buck, Benjamin Jackson(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Carla Richardson(Keele University), Gwendoline Wilkes(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Judith Clarke(UK Dementia Research Institute), Lisa Ryan(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Oliver Matias(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), David Mangion(University of Nottingham), Anya G. Hardwick, Carmen Constantin(Keele University), Ian Thomas(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Kimberley Netherton(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Skarlet Markova(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Amanda Hedstrom, B Rushton(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Craig Hyde(Keele University), Jon Scott(UK Dementia Research Institute), Mervin Blair(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Mohana Maddula(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Richard Donnelly(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), S Keane(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Sharon A. Johnson(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Helen McKenzie(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Aniruddha Banerjee, David Hutchinson(University of Nottingham), H Goodhand(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Jack D. Hill(Dalhousie University), Katrina Mellows(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Michelle Cheeseman(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), V McTaggart(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Theresa Foster(Oslo University Hospital), L Prothero(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Pushpa Saksena(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Anna C. O’Kelly, H R Wyllie(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Christian Hacon(Keele University), H Nutt(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), James North(UK Dementia Research Institute), Karolien Goffin(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), John F. Potter(University of East Anglia), Alison Wiltshire, Garth Ravenhill(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Kerstin Metcalf(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), L. Ford(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), M Langley(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), William Davison(University of Nottingham), Sivarao Subramonian(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Frederick Magezi(University of California, Los Angeles), IE Obi(University of Leicester), Nigel Temple(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Nicola Butterworth‐Cowin(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), P Oqwusu-Agyei(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), A Azim, Anne Nicolson, Javed Imam(UK Dementia Research Institute), John R. White(UK Dementia Research Institute), Lisa J. Wood(University of Nottingham), Rachael Fothergill(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Nicholas J. Thompson(University of Leicester), J. Michael Lazarus(UK Dementia Research Institute), H Werts(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), L. Sztriha(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Chau Ho(University of Nottingham), Emma McKenzie(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Emmanuelle Owoyele(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Joyce Lim(UK Dementia Research Institute), J Aeron‐Thomas(UK Dementia Research Institute), M Dockey(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Nwaosu H. Sylvester(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Pragna Rao(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Ben Bloom, Esther Erumere(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Gary L. Norman(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Imogen Skene(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), L Cuenoud(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Laura Howaniec(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Olivia Boulton(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), P Daboo(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), R Michael(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Saad Mohammed Alsaadi(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Tim Harrison(Oslo University Hospital), Hashmath Ulla Syed(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Lucia Argandona(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), S Amiani(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Richard Perry(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Amy Ashton, A. Banaras, Caroline Hogan(Keele University), C Watchurst(Keele University), Emma Elliott(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Nadia Francia(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Nobuyoshi Oji(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Renuka Erande(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), S Obarey(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Shez Feerick(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Sifelani Tshuma(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), E. B. England(University of Nottingham), Helen Pocock(University of London), K Poole(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Smita Manchanda(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Ian Burn(University of Nottingham), Sujay Dayal(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Katherine McNee(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Matthew K. Robinson(University of Leicester), Rebecca Hancock(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Andrew M. South, Clive Holmes(Keele University), A Steele, Lucy Belle Guthrie, Michael Oborn(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Azlisham Mohd Nor, Benjamin Hyams(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Charlotte Eglinton(Keele University), Dean Waugh(University of Nottingham), E. Van Cann(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Natasha Wilmhurst(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Sam Piesley(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Steven Shave(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Dipankar Dutta(University of Nottingham), Michel Obéid(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), D Ward(UK Dementia Research Institute), Jennifer Turfrey(UK Dementia Research Institute), Jon Glass(UK Dementia Research Institute), K Bowstead(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Linda Hill(Dalhousie University), Paul A. Brown(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Susan Beames(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Susan O’Çonnell(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Victoria Hughes(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Robert F. Whiting(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), James Gagg(UK Dementia Research Institute), Murtaza Hussain(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), M Harvey(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Dumin Karunatilake(University of Nottingham), Bhaskar Pusuluri(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Alexis Witcher, C. J. Pawley(Keele University), Jane Allen(UK Dementia Research Institute), Jayne Foot(UK Dementia Research Institute), Jacob M. Rowe(UK Dementia Research Institute), Catherine Lane(Keele University), Suzanne Ragab(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Beverley Wadams(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Judith Dube(UK Dementia Research Institute), Becky Jupp(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Anja Ljubez, Caroline Bagnall(Keele University), Gail Hann(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Laura Tucker(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), M Kelton(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Sean C. Orr(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Frances Harrington(University of California, Los Angeles), Alex James, Anne Lydon, Gillian Courtauld(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Kathryn Bond(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Linda F. Lucas(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Toby Nisbett(Oslo University Hospital), J Kubie(UK Dementia Research Institute), A Bowring, Georgiana Jennings(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Kevin E. Thorpe(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Nicholas Mason(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Samantha Keenan(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), L Gbadomishi(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Deborah Howcroft(University of Nottingham), Herbert B. Newton(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), James Choulerton(UK Dementia Research Institute), Joanne Avis(UK Dementia Research Institute), Louise Shaw(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Phyllis G. Paterson(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Philip Kaye(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Sarah Hierons(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Sue Lucas(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Philip Clatworthy(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Beverley Faulkner(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Lisa Rannigan(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Ruth Worner(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Biju Bhaskaran(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Afaq Saulat, Helen Bearne(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Joanne Garfield-Smith(UK Dementia Research Institute), Kathleen Horan(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Pauline Fitzell(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Susan Szabo(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Michael Haley(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), D Simmons(University of Nottingham), Donna Cotterill(University of Nottingham), G. Saunders(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Harvey Dymond(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), S Beech(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Khalid Rashed(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Alfonso Tanate, C Buckley(Keele University), Diane P. Wood(University of Nottingham), L Matthews(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), S Board(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), T Pitt-Kirby(Oslo University Hospital), Nigel Rees(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Cormac Convery(Keele University), Paul D. Jones(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Catherine Bryant(Keele University), Helen Tench(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Mark Dixon(University of Nottingham), Ronda Loosley(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), S Coetzee(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Sophie Jones(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Tasha N. Sims(Oslo University Hospital), Manju Krishnan(University of Nottingham), Caroline Davies(Keele University), Leanne Quinn(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), L Connor(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Mushtaq Ahmad Wani(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Sharon Storton(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Shelley Treadwell(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Talat Anjum(Oslo University Hospital), Chandrashekaraiah Somashekar(Keele University), Alexa J. Chandler, Claire Triscott(Keele University), L. Bevan(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Michael Sander(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Stephen Buckle(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Wadida H. El Sayed(University of Nottingham), Karen L. Andrews(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), L Hughes(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Rebecca Hughes(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Mandy Ward(UK Dementia Research Institute), Alexander Pretty, Andy Rosser, Bruce L. Davidson(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Gareth J. Price(Newcastle University), Imogen Gunson(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Jenny Lumley-Holmes(UK Dementia Research Institute), Josh Miller(UK Dementia Research Institute), Madison Larden(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Mindy Jhamat(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Paul F. Horwood(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Rhiannon Boldy(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Colin Jenkins(Keele University), Fiona Price(Newcastle University), Michael J. Harrison(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Tracey Martin(Oslo University Hospital), Noor-Us-Sabah Ahmad(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Angela Willberry, Angela Stevens, K. Fotherby(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Adrian Barry, A Remegoso, Francis Alipio(University of California, Los Angeles), H Maquire(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Joanne Hiden(UK Dementia Research Institute), K. Finney(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), R. Varquez(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Sissy Ispoglou(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Anne Hayes, D Gull(University of Nottingham), R Evans(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), E. Epstein(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), S Hurdowar(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), J. Crossley(UK Dementia Research Institute), J Miles(UK Dementia Research Institute), Kathryn Hird(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Richard Pilbery(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Chris Patterson(Keele University), Hawraman Ramadan(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Kelly Stewart(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), O Quinn(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Ruth Bellfield(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), S Macquire(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Waqas Gaba(University of Nottingham), Anil K. Nair, A. L. T. WILSON, C Hawksworth(Keele University), Irfan Alam(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Jill Greig(UK Dementia Research Institute), Matthew K. Robinson(University of Leicester), P.J. Gomes(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Pradip Rana(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Zeeshan Ahmed, P Anderston(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Andrew Neal, Deborah Walstow(University of Nottingham), Rosanna Fong(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Sean Brotheridge(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Agness Bwalya, Avrum Gillespie, C Midgley(Keele University), C Hare(Keele University), Helen N. Lyon(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), L Stephenson(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Matthew R. Broome(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), R Worton(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Stephen R. Jackson(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), R Rayessa(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Azizah Abdul Hamid, Charde Naylor(Keele University), Emma Clarkson(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Ahamad Hassan, Dean Waugh(University of Nottingham), Emelda Veraque(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Lois Finch(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Linetty Makawa(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), M Carpenter(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Prabal Datta(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Ann Needle, Louise Jackson(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Hollie Brooke, Jonathan K. Ball(UK Dementia Research Institute), T. F. Lowry(Oslo University Hospital), Sunil Punnoose(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Rachel Walker(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Veronica Murray(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Ayad K. Ali, CDR I Kamara(Keele University), Cara Doyle(Keele University), Emma Richards(Royal Hallamshire Hospital), Jo Howe(UK Dementia Research Institute), Katy Dakin(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), K. Harkness(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Ralf Lindert(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Peter Wanklyn(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Paul Willcoxson(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), P Clark-Brown(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust), Reyazul Rouf Mir(Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust)
The Lancet
February 9, 2019
Cited by 194Open Access
Full Text

Abstract

BACKGROUND: High blood pressure is common in acute stroke and is a predictor of poor outcome; however, large trials of lowering blood pressure have given variable results, and the management of high blood pressure in ultra-acute stroke remains unclear. We investigated whether transdermal glyceryl trinitrate (GTN; also known as nitroglycerin), a nitric oxide donor, might improve outcome when administered very early after stroke onset. METHODS: We did a multicentre, paramedic-delivered, ambulance-based, prospective, randomised, sham-controlled, blinded-endpoint, phase 3 trial in adults with presumed stroke within 4 h of onset, face-arm-speech-time score of 2 or 3, and systolic blood pressure 120 mm Hg or higher. Participants were randomly assigned (1:1) to receive transdermal GTN (5 mg once daily for 4 days; the GTN group) or a similar sham dressing (the sham group) in UK-based ambulances by paramedics, with treatment continued in hospital. Paramedics were unmasked to treatment, whereas participants were masked. The primary outcome was the 7-level modified Rankin Scale (mRS; a measure of functional outcome) at 90 days, assessed by central telephone follow-up with masking to treatment. Analysis was hierarchical, first in participants with a confirmed stroke or transient ischaemic attack (cohort 1), and then in all participants who were randomly assigned (intention to treat, cohort 2) according to the statistical analysis plan. This trial is registered with ISRCTN, number ISRCTN26986053. FINDINGS: Between Oct 22, 2015, and May 23, 2018, 516 paramedics from eight UK ambulance services recruited 1149 participants (n=568 in the GTN group, n=581 in the sham group). The median time to randomisation was 71 min (IQR 45-116). 597 (52%) patients had ischaemic stroke, 145 (13%) had intracerebral haemorrhage, 109 (9%) had transient ischaemic attack, and 297 (26%) had a non-stroke mimic at the final diagnosis of the index event. In the GTN group, participants' systolic blood pressure was lowered by 5·8 mm Hg compared with the sham group (p<0·0001), and diastolic blood pressure was lowered by 2·6 mm Hg (p=0·0026) at hospital admission. We found no difference in mRS between the groups in participants with a final diagnosis of stroke or transient ischaemic stroke (cohort 1): 3 (IQR 2-5; n=420) in the GTN group versus 3 (2-5; n=408) in the sham group, adjusted common odds ratio for poor outcome 1·25 (95% CI 0·97-1·60; p=0·083); we also found no difference in mRS between all patients (cohort 2: 3 [2-5]; n=544, in the GTN group vs 3 [2-5]; n=558, in the sham group; 1·04 [0·84-1·29]; p=0·69). We found no difference in secondary outcomes, death (treatment-related deaths: 36 in the GTN group vs 23 in the sham group [p=0·091]), or serious adverse events (188 in the GTN group vs 170 in the sham group [p=0·16]) between treatment groups. INTERPRETATION: Prehospital treatment with transdermal GTN does not seem to improve functional outcome in patients with presumed stroke. It is feasible for UK paramedics to obtain consent and treat patients with stroke in the ultra-acute prehospital setting. FUNDING: British Heart Foundation.


Related Papers

No related papers found

Powered by citation graph analysis