Uncovering the heterogeneity and temporal complexity of neurodegenerative diseases with Subtype and Stage Inference

Alexandra L. Young(University College London), Razvan Marinescu(University College London), Neil P. Oxtoby(University College London), Martina Bocchetta(UK Dementia Research Institute), Keir Yong(UK Dementia Research Institute), Nicholas C. Firth(University College London), David M. Cash(UK Dementia Research Institute), David L. Thomas(University College London), Katrina M. Dick(UK Dementia Research Institute), M. Jorge Cardoso(King's College London), John C. van Swieten, Barbara Borroni(University of Brescia), Daniela Galimberti(University of Milan), Mario Masellis(Sunnybrook Health Science Centre), Maria Carmela Tartaglia(University of Toronto), James B. Rowe(University of Cambridge), Caroline Graff(Karolinska Institutet), Fabrizio Tagliavini(Fondazione IRCCS Istituto Neurologico Carlo Besta), Giovanni B. Frisoni(University of Geneva), Robert Laforce(Université Laval), Elizabeth Finger(Western University), Alexandre de Mendonça(University of Lisbon), Sandro Sorbi(Don Carlo Gnocchi Foundation), Jason D. Warren(UK Dementia Research Institute), Sebastian J. Crutch(UK Dementia Research Institute), Nick C. Fox(UK Dementia Research Institute), Sébastien Ourselin(King's College London), Jonathan M. Schott(UK Dementia Research Institute), Jonathan D. Rohrer(UK Dementia Research Institute), Daniel C. Alexander(University College London), The Genetic FTD Initiative (GENFI)(Karolinska Institutet), Christin Andersson(Karolinska Institutet), Silvana Archetti(Fondazione IRCCS Ca' Granda Ospedale Maggiore Policlinico), Andrea Arighi(Fondazione IRCCS Ca' Granda Ospedale Maggiore Policlinico), Luisa Benussi(Centro San Giovanni di Dio Fatebenefratelli), Giuliano Binetti(Sunnybrook Health Science Centre), Sandra E. Black(Sunnybrook Health Science Centre), Maura Cosseddu(Karolinska University Hospital), Marie Fallström(Karolinska University Hospital), Carlos Ferreira(University of Milan), Chiara Fenoglio(University of Toronto), Morris Freedman(University of Toronto), Giorgio Fumagalli(University of Lisbon), Stefano Gazzina(Centro San Giovanni di Dio Fatebenefratelli), Roberta Ghidoni(Centro San Giovanni di Dio Fatebenefratelli), Marina Grisoli(Karolinska Institutet), Vesna Jelić(Erasmus MC), Lize C. Jiskoot(University Health Network), Ron Keren(University Health Network), Gemma Lombardi(University of Lisbon), Carolina Maruta(University of Lisbon), Lieke Meeter(Erasmus MC), Simon Mead(Erasmus MC), Rick van Minkelen(University of Lisbon), Benedetta Nacmias(University of Lisbon), Linn Öijerstedt(Karolinska Institutet), Alessandro Padovani(Erasmus MC), Jessica Panman(Erasmus MC), Michela Pievani(Centro San Giovanni di Dio Fatebenefratelli), Cristina Polito(University of Florence), Enrico Premi(Fondazione IRCCS Istituto Neurologico Carlo Besta), Sara Prioni(Mayo Clinic in Florida), Rosa Rademakers(Mayo Clinic in Florida), Veronica Redaelli(University of Toronto), Ekaterina Rogaeva(University of Toronto), Giacomina Rossi(UK Dementia Research Institute), Martin N. Rossor(Fondazione IRCCS Ca' Granda Ospedale Maggiore Policlinico), Elio Scarpini(University Health Network), David F. Tang‐Wai(University Health Network), Håkan Thonberg(University Health Network), Pietro Tiraboschi(University Health Network), Ana Verdelho(University of Lisbon), The Alzheimer’s Disease Neuroimaging Initiative (ADNI)(UC San Diego Health System), Michael W. Weiner(Mayo Clinic), Paul Aisen(Mayo Clinic), Ronald Petersen(Mayo Clinic), Clifford R. Jack(Mayo Clinic), William J. Jagust(LAC+USC Medical Center), John Q. Trojanowki(University of Pennsylvania), Arthur W. Toga(Brigham and Women's Hospital), Laurel Beckett(Indiana University Bloomington), Robert C. Green(Brigham and Women's Hospital), Andrew J. Saykin(Indiana University Bloomington), John C. Morris(Washington University in St. Louis), Leslie M. Shaw(Siemens (Germany)), Zaven S. Khachaturian(University of Pittsburgh), Greg Sorensen(Siemens (Germany)), Lew Kuller(University of Pittsburgh), Marc Raichle(Albert Einstein College of Medicine), Steven M. Paul(Alzheimer's Drug Discovery Foundation), Peter Davies(Albert Einstein College of Medicine), Howard Fillit(Alzheimer's Drug Discovery Foundation), Franz Hefti(Northwestern University), Davie Holtzman(Washington University in St. Louis), M. Marcel Mesulam(Northwestern University), William C. Potter(Eli Lilly (United States)), Peter J. Snyder(University of Washington), Adam Schwartz(Eli Lilly (United States)), Tom Montine(University of Washington), Ronald G. Thomas(UC San Diego Health System), Michael Donohue(UC San Diego Health System), Sarah Walter(UC San Diego Health System), Devon Gessert(UC San Diego Health System), Tamie Sather(UC San Diego Health System), Gus Jiminez(Mayo Clinic), Danielle Harvey(University of California, Davis), Matt A. Bernstein(Mayo Clinic), Paul Thompson(Mayo Clinic), Norbert Schuff(Mayo Clinic), Bret Borowski(Mayo Clinic), Jeff Gunter(Mayo Clinic), Matthew L. Senjem(Mayo Clinic), Prashanthi Vemuri(Mayo Clinic), David T. Jones(Mayo Clinic), Kejal Kantarci(Mayo Clinic), Chad Ward(Mayo Clinic), Robert A. Koeppe(Alzheimer's Association), Norm Foster(Alzheimer's Association), Eric M. Reiman(Alzheimer's Association), Kewei Chen(Alzheimer's Association), Chet Mathis(University of Pittsburgh), Susan Landau(Berkeley College), Nigel J. Cairns(Washington University in St. Louis), Erin Householder(Washington University in St. Louis), Lisa Taylor‐Reinwald(Washington University in St. Louis), Virginia M.‐Y. Lee(University of Pennsylvania), Magdalena Korecka(LAC+USC Medical Center), Michal Figurski(LAC+USC Medical Center), Karen Crawford(LAC+USC Medical Center), Scott Neu(LAC+USC Medical Center), Tatiana Foroud(Indiana University Bloomington), Steven Potkin(University of Michigan), Li Shen(Indiana University Bloomington), Kelley Faber(Indiana University Bloomington), Sungeun Kim(UC San Diego Health System), Kwangsik Nho(Indiana University Bloomington), Leon J. Thal(Johns Hopkins University), Neil Buckholtz(National Institute on Aging), Marylyn Albert(Johns Hopkins University), R.T. Frank(Oregon Health & Science University), John Hsiao(Oregon Health & Science University), Jeffrey Kaye(Oregon Health & Science University), Joseph F. Quinn(Oregon Health & Science University), Betty Lind(Oregon Health & Science University), Raina Carter(LAC+USC Medical Center), Sara Dolen(LAC+USC Medical Center), Lon S. Schneider(LAC+USC Medical Center), Sonia Pawluczyk(LAC+USC Medical Center), Mauricio Beccera(LAC+USC Medical Center), Liberty Teodoro(LAC+USC Medical Center), Bryan M. Spann(LAC+USC Medical Center), James M. Brewer(UC San Diego Health System), Helen Vanderswag(University of Michigan), Adam Fleisher(Alzheimer's Association), Judith L. Heidebrink(Mayo Clinic), Joanne Lord(Mayo Clinic), Sara S. Mason(Mayo Clinic), Colleen S. Albers(Mayo Clinic), David S. Knopman(Mayo Clinic), Kris Johnson(Brigham and Women's Hospital), Rachelle S. Doody(Baylor College of Medicine), Javier Villanueva‐Meyer(Baylor College of Medicine), Munir Chowdhury(Baylor College of Medicine), Susan Rountree(Baylor College of Medicine), Mimi Dang(Baylor College of Medicine), Yaakov Stern(Baylor College of Medicine), Lawrence S. Honig(Baylor College of Medicine), Karen L. Bell(Baylor College of Medicine), Beau M. Ances(Washington University in St. Louis), Maria Carroll(Washington University in St. Louis), Sue Leon(Washington University in St. Louis), Mark A. Mintun(Washington University in St. Louis), Stacy Schneider(Washington University in St. Louis), Angela Oliver(Washington University in St. Louis), Daniel Marson(University of Alabama at Birmingham), Randall Griffith(University of Alabama at Birmingham), David W. Clark(University of Alabama at Birmingham), David Geldmacher(University of Alabama at Birmingham), John Brockington(University of Alabama at Birmingham), Erik D. Roberson(University of Alabama at Birmingham), Hillel Grossman(Rush University Medical Center), Effie Mitsis(Rush University Medical Center), Leyla de Toledo‐Morrell(Rush University Medical Center), Raj C. Shah(Rush University Medical Center), Ranjan Duara, Daniel Varón, Maria T. Greig(Johns Hopkins University), Peggy Roberts(Johns Hopkins University), Marilyn Albert(Johns Hopkins University), Chiadi U. Onyike(Johns Hopkins University), Daniel D’Agostino(New York University), Stephanie Kielb(Johns Hopkins University), James E. Galvin(New York University), Brittany Cerbone(New York University), Christina A. Michel(New York University), Henry Rusinek(New York University), Mony J. de Leon(New York University), Lidia Glodzik(Duke Medical Center), Susan De Santi(Duke Medical Center), P. Murali Doraiswamy(Duke Medical Center), Jeffrey R. Petrella(Duke Medical Center), Terence Z. Wong(Duke Medical Center), Steven E. Arnold(University of Pennsylvania), Jason Karlawish(University of Kentucky), David A. Wolk(University of Kentucky), Charles D. Smith(University of Kentucky), Gregory A. Jicha(University of Kentucky), Peter Hardy(University of Kentucky), Partha Sinha(University of Kentucky), Elizabeth Oates(University of Kentucky), Gary Conrad(University of Kentucky), Oscar L. López(Johns Hopkins University), MaryAnn Oakley(University of Pittsburgh), Donna M. Simpson(Johns Hopkins University), Anton P. Porsteinsson(University of Rochester Medical Center), Bonnie S. Goldstein(University of Rochester Medical Center), Kim Martin(University of Rochester Medical Center), Kelly M. Makino(University of Rochester Medical Center), M. Saleem Ismail(University of Rochester Medical Center), Connie Brand(University of Rochester Medical Center), Ruth A. Mulnard(UC Irvine Health), Gaby Thai(UC Irvine Health), Catherine Mc-Adams-Ortiz(UC Irvine Health), Kyle Womack(The University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center), Dana Mathews(The University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center), Mary Quiceno(The University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center), Ramon Diaz‐Arrastia(The University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center), Richard King(The University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center), Myron Weiner(University of California, San Francisco), Kristen Martin-Cook(Emory University), Michael D. Devous(Emory University), Allan I. Levey(Emory University), James J. Lah(Emory University), Janet S. Cellar(Emory University), Jeffrey M. Burns(University of Kansas Medical Center), Heather S. Anderson(University of Kansas Medical Center), Russell H. Swerdlow(University of Kansas Medical Center), Liana Apostolova, Kathleen Tingus, Ellen Woo, Daniel Silverman, Po H. Lu(WinnMed), George Bartzokis(WinnMed), Neill R. Graff‐Radford(WinnMed), Francine Parfitt(WinnMed), Tracy Kendall(WinnMed), Heather Johnson(WinnMed), Martin R. Farlow(Indiana University Bloomington), Ann Marie Hake(Indiana University Bloomington), Brandy R. Matthews(Indiana University Bloomington), Scott Herring(Yale University), Cynthia Hunt(Yale University), Christopher H. van Dyck(Yale University), Richard E. Carson(Jewish General Hospital), Martha G. MacAvoy(Jewish General Hospital), Howard Chertkow(Jewish General Hospital), Howard Bergman(Sunnybrook Health Science Centre), Chris Hosein(Sunnybrook Health Science Centre), Bojana Stefanovic(Sunnybrook Health Science Centre), Curtis Caldwell(Sunnybrook Health Science Centre), Ging‐Yuek Robin Hsiung(University of British Columbia), Howard Feldman(University of British Columbia), Benita Mudge(University of British Columbia), Michele Assaly(University of British Columbia), Andrew Kertesz(Cleveland Clinic), John Rogers(St Joseph's Health Care), Charles Bernick(Northwestern University), Donna Munic(Northwestern University), Diana Kerwin(Northwestern University), Marek-Marsel Mesulam(Northwestern University), Kristine Lipowski(Northwestern University), Chuang-Kuo Wu(Northwestern University), Nancy Johnson(Northwestern University), Carl Sadowsky(Palm Beach Neurology), Walter Martínez(Georgetown University), Teresa Villena(Georgetown University), Raymond Scott Turner(Georgetown University), Kathleen Johnson(Brigham and Women's Hospital), Brigid Reynolds(Brigham and Women's Hospital), Reisa A. Sperling(Brigham and Women's Hospital), Keith A. Johnson(Brigham and Women's Hospital), Gad Marshall(Brigham and Women's Hospital), Meghan Frey(Brigham and Women's Hospital), Barton Lane(Brigham and Women's Hospital), Allyson Rosen(Brigham and Women's Hospital), Jared Tinklenberg(Brigham and Women's Hospital), Marwan N. Sabbagh(Banner Sun Health Research Institute), Christine M. Belden(Banner Sun Health Research Institute), Sandra A. Jacobson(Boston University), Sherye A. Sirrel(Boston University), Neil W. Kowall(Boston University), Ronald Killiany(Boston University), Andrew E. Budson(Boston University), Alexander Norbash(Boston University), Patricia Lynn Johnson(Boston University), Joanne Allard(Howard University), Alan J. Lerner(Case Western Reserve University), Paula Ogrocki(Case Western Reserve University), Leon Hudson(Case Western Reserve University), Evan Fletcher(University of California, Davis), Owen Carmichael(University of California, Davis), John Olichney(Neurological Surgery), Charles DeCarli(Parkwood Institute), Smita Kittur(Parkwood Institute), Michael Borrie(Parkwood Institute), T-Y Lee(University of Wisconsin–Madison), Robert Bartha(University of Wisconsin–Madison), Sterling C. Johnson(University of Wisconsin–Madison), Sanjay Asthana(University of Wisconsin–Madison), Cynthia M. Carlsson(University of Wisconsin–Madison), Steven G. Potkin(University of Michigan), Adrian Preda(Alzheimer's Association), Dana Nguyen(Alzheimer's Association), Pierre N. Tariot(Alzheimer's Association), Stephanie Reeder(Alzheimer's Association), Vernice Bates(Dent Neurologic Institute), Horacio Capote(Dent Neurologic Institute), Michelle Rainka(Dent Neurologic Institute), Douglas W. Scharre(The Ohio State University), Maria Kataki(The Ohio State University), Anahita Adeli(The Ohio State University), Earl A. Zimmerman(Albany Medical Center Hospital), Dzintra Celmins(Hartford Hospital), Alice D. Brown(Hartford Hospital), Godfrey D. Pearlson(Hartford Hospital), Karen Blank(Dartmouth–Hitchcock Medical Center), Karen Anderson(Dartmouth–Hitchcock Medical Center), Robert B. Santulli(Dartmouth–Hitchcock Medical Center), Tamar J. Kitzmiller(Dartmouth–Hitchcock Medical Center), Eben S. Schwartz(Dartmouth–Hitchcock Medical Center), Kaycee M. Sink(Wake Forest University), Jeff D. Williamson(Wake Forest University), Pradeep Garg(Providence College), Franklin Watkins(Providence College), Brian R. Ott(Providence College), Henry Querfurth(Providence College), Geoffrey Tremont(Providence College), Stephen Salloway(Providence College), Paul Malloy(University of California, San Francisco), Stephen Correia(University of California, San Francisco), Howard J. Rosen(Medical University of South Carolina), Bruce L. Miller(Medical University of South Carolina), Jacobo Mintzer(Medical University of South Carolina), Kenneth Spicer(Medical University of South Carolina), David Bachman(Medical University of South Carolina), Stephen Pasternak(St Joseph's Health Care), Irina Rachinsky(Nathan Kline Institute for Psychiatric Research), Dick Drost(Nathan Kline Institute for Psychiatric Research), Nunzio Pomara(Nathan Kline Institute for Psychiatric Research), Raymundo Hernando(Nathan Kline Institute for Psychiatric Research), Antero Sarrael(Nathan Kline Institute for Psychiatric Research), Susan K. Schultz(University of Iowa), Laura L. Boles Ponto(University of Iowa), Hyungsub Shim(University of Iowa), Karen E. Smith(University of Iowa), Norman Relkin(Cornell University), Gloria Chaing(Cornell University), Lisa Raudin(Cornell University), Amanda Smith(University of South Florida), Kristin Fargher(University of California, San Francisco), Balebail Ashok Raj(Northwestern University), Thomas C. Neylan(University of California, San Francisco), Jordan Grafman(Northwestern University), Melissa Davis(University of California, San Francisco), Rosemary Morrison(University of California, San Francisco), Jacqueline Hayes(United States Department of Defense), Shannon Finley(Rush University Medical Center), Karl E. Friedl(Rush University Medical Center), Debra Fleischman(Rush University Medical Center), Konstantinos Arfanakis(Rush University Medical Center), Olga James(University of Wisconsin–Madison), Dino Massoglia(University of Wisconsin–Madison), J. Jay Fruehling(University of Wisconsin–Madison), Sandra Harding(University of Wisconsin–Madison), Elaine R. Peskind(University of Washington), Eric C. Petrie(The Ohio State University), Gail Li(The Ohio State University), Jerome A. Yesavage(Stanford University), Joy L. Taylor(Stanford University), Ansgar J. Furst(Stanford University)
Nature Communications
October 9, 2018
Cited by 574Open Access
Full Text

Abstract

Abstract The heterogeneity of neurodegenerative diseases is a key confound to disease understanding and treatment development, as study cohorts typically include multiple phenotypes on distinct disease trajectories. Here we introduce a machine-learning technique—Subtype and Stage Inference (SuStaIn)—able to uncover data-driven disease phenotypes with distinct temporal progression patterns, from widely available cross-sectional patient studies. Results from imaging studies in two neurodegenerative diseases reveal subgroups and their distinct trajectories of regional neurodegeneration. In genetic frontotemporal dementia, SuStaIn identifies genotypes from imaging alone, validating its ability to identify subtypes; further the technique reveals within-genotype heterogeneity. In Alzheimer’s disease, SuStaIn uncovers three subtypes, uniquely characterising their temporal complexity. SuStaIn provides fine-grained patient stratification, which substantially enhances the ability to predict conversion between diagnostic categories over standard models that ignore subtype ( p = 7.18 × 10 −4 ) or temporal stage ( p = 3.96 × 10 −5 ). SuStaIn offers new promise for enabling disease subtype discovery and precision medicine.


Related Papers

No related papers found

Powered by citation graph analysis