Availability and affordability of blood pressure-lowering medicines and the effect on blood pressure control in high-income, middle-income, and low-income countries: an analysis of the PURE study data

Marjan Walli-Attaei(McMaster University), Rasha Khatib(Loyola University Medical Center), Martin McKee(London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine), Scott A. Lear(Simon Fraser University), Gilles R. Dagenais(Université Laval), Ehimario Igumbor(University of the Western Cape), Khalid F. AlHabib(King Saud University), Manmeet Kaur(Post Graduate Institute of Medical Education and Research), Iolanthé M. Kruger(North-West University), Koon Teo(Population Health Research Institute), Fernando Laņas(Universidad de La Frontera), Khalid Yusoff(Hospital Sungai Buloh), Aytekin Oğuz(Istanbul Medeniyet University), Rajeev Gupta(Eternal Hospital), Afzalhussein Yusufali(Dubai Health Authority), Ahmad Bahonar(Isfahan University of Medical Sciences), Raman Kutty(Health Action by People), Annika Rosengren(University of Gothenburg), Viswanathan Mohan(Madras Diabetes Research Foundation), Álvaro Avezum(Instituto Dante Pazzanese de Cardiologia), Rita Yusuf(Independent University), Andrzej Szuba(Wroclaw Medical University), Sumathy Rangarajan(Population Health Research Institute), Clara K Chow(The University of Sydney), Salim Yusuf(Population Health Research Institute), Salim Yusuf(Population Health Research Institute), Sumathy Rangarajan(Population Health Research Institute), Koon Teo(Population Health Research Institute), Clara K Chow(The University of Sydney), Martin O’Donnell(Population Health Research Institute), Andrew Mente, Darryl P. Leong, Andrew Smyth, Philip Joseph, Shofiqul Islam, M Zhang(Population Health Research Institute), Weiwei Hu(Dubai Health Authority), Chinthanie Ramasundarahettige(The University of Sydney), Gary Wong, Lovely Dayal(Population Health Research Institute), Amparo Casanova, Mahshid Dehghan(Population Health Research Institute), Gregory D. Lewis, Antonio Aliberti, Álvaro Reyes, Ahmed Zaki, Basil S. Lewis(Wroclaw Medical University), B Zhang(Wroclaw Medical University), D Agapay, Danielle M. Hari, E Milazzo, E Ramezani, F Hussain(Population Health Research Institute), Fathimath Shifaly(Population Health Research Institute), I Kay, Julija Rimac(Population Health Research Institute), John G. Swallow(Population Health Research Institute), L Heldman(Population Health Research Institute), Maha Mushtaha(Population Health Research Institute), Maha Mushtaha(Madras Diabetes Research Foundation), Mark Trottier(Population Health Research Institute), N Aoucheva, N Kandy, Pam Mackie, R Solano, Siu Lim Chin, S Ramacham, Sadequa Shahrook, S Trottier, T Tongana, W Elsheikh(The University of Sydney), J Lindeman(Population Health Research Institute), Matt J. McQueen(Population Health Research Institute), Kellie Hall(University of Gothenburg), J. Keys(Population Health Research Institute), Xuechao Wang, J Keneth(Population Health Research Institute), Anitha Devanath, Rafael Díaz, Andrés Orlandini, B Linetsky(Wroclaw Medical University), S Toscanelli, Germana Casaccia, JM Maini Cuneo, Omar Rahman, Rita Yusuf(Population Health Research Institute), AK Azad(Loyola University Medical Center), Khondkar Ayaz Rabbani(University of Gothenburg), HM Cherry(Isfahan University of Medical Sciences), Adnan Mannan, I Hassan, AT Talukdar, RB Tooheen, MU Khan, Mariz Sintaha(Population Health Research Institute), Tarzia Choudhury, Md Rabiul Haque, S Parvin, Álvaro Avezum(Instituto Dante Pazzanese de Cardiologia), GB Oliveira, CS Marcílio, Antônio José Cordeiro Mattos(The University of Sydney), Koon Teo(Population Health Research Institute), Salim Yusuf(Population Health Research Institute), Jane DeJesus(Population Health Research Institute), D Agapay, T Tongana, R Solano, I Kay, S Trottier, Julija Rimac(Population Health Research Institute), W Elsheikh(The University of Sydney), L Heldman(Population Health Research Institute), E Ramezani, Gilles R. Dagenais(Université Laval), Paul Poirier, Ginette Turbide, D. Auger, A LeBlanc De Bluts, MC Proulx(London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine), Marie‐Pierre Cayer(Population Health Research Institute), Nadine Bonneville, Scott A. Lear(Simon Fraser University), Danijela Gašević, E Corber, Veronica de Jong, I Vukmirovich, Andreas Wielgosz, George Fodor, Andrew Pipe, A Shane, Fernando Laņas(Universidad de La Frontera), Pamela Serón, S Martinez, A Valdebenito, María José Oliveros(Population Health Research Institute), Li Wei(Population Health Research Institute), Liu Lisheng, Chen Chunming, Xingyu Wang, Wen­hua Zhao, Zhang Hongye, JiaXuan, Bo Hu(University of the Western Cape), Yi Sun, Jian Bo(University of the Western Cape), Zhao Xiuwen, Chang Xiaohong, Tao Chen, Hui Chen, Chang Xiaohong, Qing Deng, Xiaoru Cheng, Qing Deng, He Xinye(North-West University), Bo Hu(University of the Western Cape), JiaXuan, Jian Li(Population Health Research Institute), Juan Li(Population Health Research Institute), Xu Liu, Ren Bing(University of Gothenburg), Yi Sun, Wang Wei, Yang Wang, Yang Jun, Yi Zhai, Zhang Hongye, Zhao Xiuwen, Zhu Manlu, Fanghong Lu, Jianfang Wu, Yindong Li(Population Health Research Institute), Yan Hou, Liangqing Zhang, Baoxia Guo, Liao Xiaoyang, Shiying Zhang, BianRongwen, TianXiuzhen, Dong Li(Population Health Research Institute), Di Chen, Wu Jianguo, Xiao Yize, Tianlu Liu, Peng Zhang, Changlin Dong, Li Ning(Population Health Research Institute), Xiaolan Ma(Population Health Research Institute), Yang Yuqing, Lei Rensheng, Fu Minfan, Jing He(North-West University), Yü Liu(Population Health Research Institute), Xiaojie Xing, Zhou Qiang, Patricio López‐Jaramillo, Paul Anthony Camacho, R Garcia, LJA Jurado, Diego Gómez-Arbeláez, JF Arguello, R Dueñas, S Silva, LP Pradilla, F Ramírez(Population Health Research Institute), DI Molina, Carlos Cure-Cure(The University of Sydney), Suhey Pérez(Population Health Research Institute), E Hernandez, E. Arcos, S Fernandez, Claudia Narváez(The University of Sydney), J Paez(Population Health Research Institute), A Sotomayor, Henry García(Population Health Research Institute), G. Sánchez, T David, A Rico, Prem Mony, Mário Vaz(Population Health Research Institute), A V Bharathi, Sumathi Swaminathan, Kiruba Shankar(University of Gothenburg), AV Kurpad(Instituto Dante Pazzanese de Cardiologia), KG Jayachitra, Narinder Kumar, Viswanathan Mohan(Madras Diabetes Research Foundation), Mohan Deepa(Madras Diabetes Research Foundation), K Parthiban(Population Health Research Institute), M Anitha(University of Gothenburg), S Hemavathy(Population Health Research Institute), T Rahulashankiruthiyayan, D Anitha, K Sridevi, Rajeev Gupta(Eternal Hospital), RB Panwar(Eternal Hospital), Indu Mohan, Priyanka Rastogi(Madras Diabetes Research Foundation), S. Rastogi, R. Bhargava, Rajesh Kumar, JS Thakur, Binod Kumar Patro(Wroclaw Medical University), P. V. M. Lakshmi(Wroclaw Medical University), R Mahajan, P Chaudary, V. Raman Kutty, K. Vijayakumar(Health Action by People), K Ajayan(University of Gothenburg), G Rajasree(University of Gothenburg), AR Renjini, A Deepu(The University of Sydney), B. Sandhya, Stephen Asha(Wroclaw Medical University), HS Soumya(Loyola University Medical Center), Roya Kelishadi, Ahmad Bahonar(Isfahan University of Medical Sciences), Noushin Mohammadifard(Isfahan University of Medical Sciences), Hadi Heidari, Khalid Yusoff(Population Health Research Institute), TST Ismail(UCSI University), KK Ng, A Devi(Population Health Research Institute), NM Nasir, MM Yasin(Population Health Research Institute), Maizatullifah Miskan, EA Rahman(Population Health Research Institute), MKM Arsad(Simon Fraser University), Farnaza Ariffin, SA Razak(Population Health Research Institute), FA Majid(Population Health Research Institute), NA Bakar(Wroclaw Medical University), MY Yacob(Madras Diabetes Research Foundation), N Zainon(Population Health Research Institute), Ruhaya Salleh, MKA Ramli, NA Halim, SR Norlizan(Madras Diabetes Research Foundation), NM Ghazali, MN Arshad(Population Health Research Institute), R Razali, Syed Hassan Ali, HR Othman(Population Health Research Institute), CWJCW Hafar, A Pit, Norlaila Danuri, F Basir, SNA Zahari(Population Health Research Institute), Hafez Mohammad Ammar Abdullah, MA Arippin(Population Health Research Institute), NA Zakaria(Population Health Research Institute), I Noorhassim(Madras Diabetes Research Foundation), MJ Hasni, MT Azmi, MI Zaleha, KY Hazdi, AR Rizam, W Sazman(The University of Sydney), A Azman(The University of Sydney), Rasha Khatib(Loyola University Medical Center), Umaiyeh Khammash(Loyola University Medical Center), A Khatib, Rita Giacaman(Loyola University Medical Center), Romania Iqbal, Asad Afridi, Rehman Khawaja, Auriba Raza, Khawar Kazmi, Antonio Dans(University of Gothenburg), HU Co, JT Sanchez(Simon Fraser University), L Pudol, C Zamora-Pudol(Population Health Research Institute), LAM Palileo-Villanueva(The University of Sydney), MR Aquino, C Abaquin, SL Pudol(The University of Sydney), ML Cabral, Witold Zatoński, Andrzej Szuba(The University of Sydney), Katarzyna Zatońska(Wroclaw Medical University), Rafał Ilow(University of Gothenburg), M Ferus, Bożena Regulska−Ilow(Population Health Research Institute), Dorota Różańska(Wroclaw Medical University), Maria Wołyniec, Khalid F. AlHabib(King Saud University), Ahmad Hersi(King Saud University), Tarek Kashour, Hussam AlFaleh, Mostafa Q. Alshamiri(Population Health Research Institute), HB Altaradi(Population Health Research Institute), Omar Alnobani, A Bafart, Nour Alkamel, Mohammed K. Ali, Mahera Abdulrahman(Population Health Research Institute), Reza Nouri(Population Health Research Institute), A. Kruger, H H Voster(North-West University), Aletta E. Schutte, Edelweiss Wentzel‐Viljoen, FC Eloff, H de Ridder, H Moss(Population Health Research Institute), J Potgieter(Population Health Research Institute), A.V. Diez Roux(Population Health Research Institute), Megan Watson, G de Wet(Population Health Research Institute), Antonel Olckers, Johann C. Jerling, Marlien Pieters, Trynke Hoekstra(Population Health Research Institute), Thandi Puoane, Ehimario Igumbor(University of the Western Cape), Lungiswa Tsolekile(University of the Western Cape), David Sanders(Population Health Research Institute), Pooveshni Naidoo, N Steyn, Nasheeta Peer, Bongani M. Mayosi, Brian Rayner(Wroclaw Medical University), Estelle V. Lambert(Wroclaw Medical University), Naomi Levitt, Tracy Kolbe‐Alexander, Lucas Ntyintyane, G. Hughes(Population Health Research Institute), Rina Swart, Jean Fourie, Moïse Muzigaba(Population Health Research Institute), S Xapa(Population Health Research Institute), N Gobile, K Ndayi, B Jwili(University of Gothenburg), K Ndibaza(Wroclaw Medical University), Bonaventure Amandi Egbujie(University of Gothenburg), Annika Rosengren(Wroclaw Medical University), Kristina Bengtsson Boström(University of Gothenburg), U Lindblad, P Langkilde, A Gustavsson, Mattias Andréasson, M Snällman(Population Health Research Institute), L Wirdemann(Population Health Research Institute), Karen Odberg Pettersson(Population Health Research Institute), Erik Moberg(University of Gothenburg), Karen Yeates, Jessica Sleeth(University of Gothenburg), Kajiru Kilonzo(Population Health Research Institute), Aytekin Oğuz(Istanbul Medeniyet University), AAK Akalin(Istanbul Medeniyet University), KBT Calik, Neşe İmeryüz, Ahmet Temizhan, Emel Alphan, E Gunes, Haydar Sur, K Karsidag(Population Health Research Institute), S Gulec(University of Gothenburg), Yüksel Altuntaş, AM Yusufali(Dubai Health Authority), Wael Almahmeed(Dubai Health Authority), H Swidan(The University of Sydney), EA Darwish(Population Health Research Institute), ARA Hashemi(Simon Fraser University), Najib Al‐Khaja(The University of Sydney), J. Muscat-Baron, SH Ahmed, TM Mamdouh(Loyola University Medical Center), WM Darwish, MHS Abdelmotagali, SA Omer Awed, GA Movahedi, F Hussain, H Al Shaibani(Population Health Research Institute), RIM Gharabou(UCSI University), DF Youssef, AZS Nawati(King Saud University), ZAR Abu Salah, RFE Abdalla, SM Al Shuwaihi, MA Al Omairi, OD Cadigal, R.S. Alejandrino, Jephat Chifamba, Lenon Gwaunza(Population Health Research Institute), G Terera(Population Health Research Institute), Carol Mahachi, Pretty Murambiwa(The University of Sydney), T Machiweni, RF Mapanga
The Lancet Public Health
September 1, 2017
Cited by 214Open Access
Full Text

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Hypertension is considered the most important risk factor for cardiovascular diseases, but its control is poor worldwide. We aimed to assess the availability and affordability of blood pressure-lowering medicines, and the association with use of these medicines and blood pressure control in countries at varying levels of economic development. METHODS: We analysed the availability, costs, and affordability of blood pressure-lowering medicines with data recorded from 626 communities in 20 countries participating in the Prospective Urban Rural Epidemiological (PURE) study. Medicines were considered available if they were present in the local pharmacy when surveyed, and affordable if their combined cost was less than 20% of the households' capacity to pay. We related information about availability and affordability to use of these medicines and blood pressure control with multilevel mixed-effects logistic regression models, and compared results for high-income, upper-middle-income, lower-middle-income, and low-income countries. Data for India are presented separately because it has a large generic pharmaceutical industry and a higher availability of medicines than other countries at the same economic level. FINDINGS: The availability of two or more classes of blood pressure-lowering drugs was lower in low-income and middle-income countries (except for India) than in high-income countries. The proportion of communities with four drug classes available was 94% in high-income countries (108 of 115 communities), 76% in India (68 of 90), 71% in upper-middle-income countries (90 of 126), 47% in lower-middle-income countries (107 of 227), and 13% in low-income countries (nine of 68). The proportion of households unable to afford two blood pressure-lowering medicines was 31% in low-income countries (1069 of 3479 households), 9% in middle-income countries (5602 of 65 471), and less than 1% in high-income countries (44 of 10 880). Participants with known hypertension in communities that had all four drug classes available were more likely to use at least one blood pressure-lowering medicine (adjusted odds ratio [OR] 2·23, 95% CI 1·59-3·12); p<0·0001), combination therapy (1·53, 1·13-2·07; p=0·054), and have their blood pressure controlled (2·06, 1·69-2·50; p<0·0001) than were those in communities where blood pressure-lowering medicines were not available. Participants with known hypertension from households able to afford four blood pressure-lowering drug classes were more likely to use at least one blood pressure-lowering medicine (adjusted OR 1·42, 95% CI 1·25-1·62; p<0·0001), combination therapy (1·26, 1·08-1·47; p=0·0038), and have their blood pressure controlled (1·13, 1·00-1·28; p=0·0562) than were those unable to afford the medicines. INTERPRETATION: A large proportion of communities in low-income and middle-income countries do not have access to more than one blood pressure-lowering medicine and, when available, they are often not affordable. These factors are associated with poor blood pressure control. Ensuring access to affordable blood pressure-lowering medicines is essential for control of hypertension in low-income and middle-income countries. FUNDING: Population Health Research Institute, the Canadian Institutes of Health Research, Heart and Stroke Foundation of Ontario, Canadian Institutes of Health Research Strategy for Patient Oriented Research through the Ontario SPOR Support Unit, the Ontario Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care, pharmaceutical companies (with major contributions from AstraZeneca [Canada], Sanofi Aventis [France and Canada], Boehringer Ingelheim [Germany amd Canada], Servier, and GlaxoSmithKline), Novartis and King Pharma, and national or local organisations in participating countries.


Related Papers

No related papers found

Powered by citation graph analysis