Observation of<mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"><mml:mrow><mml:msup><mml:mrow><mml:mi>e</mml:mi></mml:mrow><mml:mrow><mml:mo>+</mml:mo></mml:mrow></mml:msup><mml:msup><mml:mrow><mml:mi>e</mml:mi></mml:mrow><mml:mrow><mml:mo>−</mml:mo></mml:mrow></mml:msup><mml:mo stretchy="false">→</mml:mo><mml:mi>γ</mml:mi><mml:mi>X</mml:mi><mml:mo stretchy="false">(</mml:mo><mml:mn>3872</mml:mn><mml:mo stretchy="false">)</mml:mo></mml:mrow></mml:math>at BESIII

M. Ablikim(Institute of High Energy Physics), M. N. Achasov(Siberian Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences), X. Ai(Institute of High Energy Physics), O. Albayrak(Carnegie Mellon University), D. J. Ambrose(University of Rochester), F. F. An(COMSATS University Islamabad), Q. An(University of Science and Technology of China), J. Z. Bai(Institute of High Energy Physics), R. Baldini Ferroli(COMSATS University Islamabad), Y. Ban(Peking University), J. V. Bennett(Indiana University Bloomington), M. Bertani(Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare, Laboratori Nazionali di Frascati), J. M. Bian(University of Minnesota), E. Boger(Joint Institute for Nuclear Research), O. Bondarenko(University of Groningen), I. Boyko(Joint Institute for Nuclear Research), S. Braun, R. A. Briere(Carnegie Mellon University), H. Cai(Wuhan University), X. Z. Cai(Institute of High Energy Physics), Ö. Çakır(Ankara University), A. Calcaterra(Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare, Laboratori Nazionali di Frascati), G. F. Cao(Institute of High Energy Physics), S. A. Çetin(Doğuş University), J. F. Chang(Institute of High Energy Physics), G. Chelkov(Joint Institute for Nuclear Research), G. Chen(Institute of High Energy Physics), H. S. Chen(Institute of High Energy Physics), J. C. Chen(Bursa Uludağ Üni̇versi̇tesi̇), M. L. Chen(Bursa Uludağ Üni̇versi̇tesi̇), S. J. Chen(Nanjing University), X. Chen(Institute of High Energy Physics), X. R. Chen(Institute of High Energy Physics), Y. B. Chen(Doğuş University), H. P. Cheng(Huangshan University), X. K. Chu(Peking University), Y. P. Chu(Institute of High Energy Physics), D. Cronin-Hennessy(University of Minnesota), H. L. Dai(Institute of High Energy Physics), J. P. Dai(Institute of High Energy Physics), D. Dedovich(Joint Institute for Nuclear Research), Z. Y. Deng(Institute of High Energy Physics), A. Denig(Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz), I. Denysenko(Joint Institute for Nuclear Research), M. Destefanis(International University College of Turin), W. M. Ding(Shandong University), Y. Ding(Liaoning University), C. Dong(Nankai University), J. Dong(Institute of High Energy Physics), L. Y. Dong(COMSATS University Islamabad), M. Y. Dong(Institute of High Energy Physics), S. X. Du(Zhengzhou University), J. Z. Fan(Tsinghua University), J. Fang(Institute of High Energy Physics), S. S. Fang(COMSATS University Islamabad), Y. Fang(Institute of High Energy Physics), L. Fava(Università degli Studi del Piemonte Orientale “Amedeo Avogadro”), C. Q. Feng(University of Science and Technology of China), C. D. Fu(Bursa Uludağ Üni̇versi̇tesi̇), J. Fu(Nanjing University), J. Fu(Joint Institute for Nuclear Research), Q. Gao(Institute of High Energy Physics), Y. Gao(Tsinghua University), C. Geng(University of Science and Technology of China), K. Goetzen(GSI Helmholtz Centre for Heavy Ion Research), W. X. Gong(Institute of High Energy Physics), W. Gradl(Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz), M. Greco(International University College of Turin), M. H. Gu(COMSATS University Islamabad), Y. T. Gu(Guangxi University), Y. Guan(COMSATS University Islamabad), A. Q. Guo(Nankai University), L. B. Guo(Nanjing Normal University), Tingting Guo(Nanjing Normal University), Y. P. Guo(Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz), Yaling Han(COMSATS University Islamabad), F. A. Harris(University of Hawaiʻi at Mānoa), K. L. He(COMSATS University Islamabad), M. He(COMSATS University Islamabad), Z. Y. He(Nankai University), T. Held(Ruhr University Bochum), Y. K. Heng(COMSATS University Islamabad), Z. L. Hou(COMSATS University Islamabad), Chenguo Hu(Nanjing Normal University), H. M. Hu(COMSATS University Islamabad), J. F. Hu, J. F. Hu(COMSATS University Islamabad), G. M. Huang(University of Science and Technology of China), G. S. Huang(University of Science and Technology of China), J.S.T. Huang(Henan Normal University), L. Q. Huang(COMSATS University Islamabad), X. T. Huang(Shandong University), Yin Huang(Nanjing University), T. Hussain(University of the Punjab), C. S. Ji(University of Science and Technology of China), Q. P. Ji(COMSATS University Islamabad), Q. P. Ji(Nankai University), X. B. Ji(COMSATS University Islamabad), X. L. Ji(COMSATS University Islamabad), L. L. Jiang(COMSATS University Islamabad), Xin Jiang(COMSATS University Islamabad), J. B. Jiao(Shandong University), Z. Jiao(Huangshan University), D. P. Jin(COMSATS University Islamabad), S. Jin(COMSATS University Islamabad), T. Johansson(Uppsala University), N. Kalantar-Nayestanaki(University of Groningen), X. L. Kang(COMSATS University Islamabad), X. S. Kang(Nankai University), M. Kavatsyuk(University of Groningen), B. Kloss(Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz), B. Kopf(Ruhr University Bochum), M. Kornicer(University of Hawaiʻi at Mānoa), W. Kuehn(COMSATS University Islamabad), A. Kupść(Uppsala University), W. Lai(COMSATS University Islamabad), J. S. Lange(COMSATS University Islamabad), M. Lara(Indiana University Bloomington), P. Larin(Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz), M. Leyhe(Ruhr University Bochum), C. H. Li(University of Science and Technology of China), Cheng Li(University of Science and Technology of China), Cui Li(University of Science and Technology of China), D. Li(Hunan University), D. M. Li(Hunan University), F. Li(COMSATS University Islamabad), G. Li(COMSATS University Islamabad), H. B. Li(Hangzhou Normal University), J. C. Li(COMSATS University Islamabad), K. Li(Shandong University), Kangwei Li(Shandong University), Lei Li(COMSATS University Islamabad), P. R. Li(Chinese Academy of Sciences), Q. J. Li(COMSATS University Islamabad), T. Li(Shandong University), W. D. Li(COMSATS University Islamabad), W. G. Li(COMSATS University Islamabad), X. L. Li(Seoul National University), X. N. Li(Seoul National University), X. Q. Li(Seoul National University), X. R. Li(Seoul National University), Z. B. Li(Sun Yat-sen University), H. Liang(University of Science and Technology of China), Y. F. Liang(Sichuan University), Y. T. Liang(COMSATS University Islamabad), D. X. Lin(COMSATS University Islamabad), B. J. Liu(Shanxi University), C. L. Liu(Institute of High Energy Physics), Chaoyi Liu(COMSATS University Islamabad), F. H. Liu(Shanxi University), Fang Liu(COMSATS University Islamabad), Feng Liu(Shanxi University), H. B. Liu(Guangxi University), H. H. Liu(Guangxi University), H. M. Liu(Guangxi University), Jingjing Liu(Wuhan University), Jingjing Liu(Wuhan University), K. Y. Liu(Liaoning University), K. Y. Liu(Liaoning University), P. L. Liu(Shandong University), Q. Liu(Chinese Academy of Sciences), S. B. Liu(University of Science and Technology of China), X. Liu(Lanzhou University), Y. B. Liu(Nankai University), Z. A. Liu(COMSATS University Islamabad), Zhiqiang Liu(COMSATS University Islamabad), Zhiqing Liu(Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz), H. Loehner(University of Groningen), X. C. Lou(COMSATS University Islamabad), G. R. Lu(Henan Normal University), H. J. Lu(COMSATS University Islamabad), H. Lu(COMSATS University Islamabad), J. G. Lu(COMSATS University Islamabad), X. R. Lu(Chinese Academy of Sciences), Y. Lu(COMSATS University Islamabad), Y. P. Lu(COMSATS University Islamabad), C. L. Luo(Nanjing Normal University), M. X. Luo(Zhejiang University), T. Luo(University of Hawaiʻi at Mānoa), X. L. Luo(COMSATS University Islamabad), M. Lv(COMSATS University Islamabad), F. C.(Liaoning University), H. Liang(COMSATS University Islamabad), Q. M.(COMSATS University Islamabad), S. Ma(COMSATS University Islamabad), T. Ma(COMSATS University Islamabad), X. Y.(COMSATS University Islamabad), F. E. Maas(COMSATS University Islamabad), M. Maggiora(International University College of Turin), Q. A. Malik(University of the Punjab), Y. J. Mao(Peking University), Z. P. Mao(COMSATS University Islamabad), J. G. Messchendorp(University of Groningen), J. Min(COMSATS University Islamabad), T. J. Min(COMSATS University Islamabad), R. E. Mitchell(Indiana University Bloomington), X. H. Mo(COMSATS University Islamabad), Y. J. Mo(Central China Normal University), H. Moeini(University of Groningen), C. Morales Morales(COMSATS University Islamabad), K. Moriya(Indiana University Bloomington), N. Yu. Muchnoi(Siberian Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences), H. Muramatsu(University of Minnesota), Y. Nefedov(Joint Institute for Nuclear Research), I. B. Nikolaev(Siberian Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences), Z. Ning(COMSATS University Islamabad), S. Nisar(COMSATS University Islamabad), X. Y. Niu(COMSATS University Islamabad), S. L. Olsen(Seoul National University), Q. Ouyang(COMSATS University Islamabad), S. Pacetti(University of Perugia), M. Pelizaeus(Ruhr University Bochum), H. P. Peng(University of Science and Technology of China), K. Peters(GSI Helmholtz Centre for Heavy Ion Research), J. L. Ping(Nanjing Normal University), R. G. Ping(COMSATS University Islamabad), R. Poling(University of Minnesota), E. Prencipe(Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz), Mingyao Qi(Nanjing University), S. Qian(COMSATS University Islamabad), C. F. Qiao(Chinese Academy of Sciences), L. Q. Qin(Shandong University), X. S. Qin(COMSATS University Islamabad), Y. Qin(Peking University), H. R. Qi(COMSATS University Islamabad), J. F. Qiu(COMSATS University Islamabad), K. H. Rashid(University of the Punjab), C. F. Redmer(Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz), M. Ripka(Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz), G. Rong(COMSATS University Islamabad), X. D. Ruan(Guangxi University), A. Sarantsev(Joint Institute for Nuclear Research), K. Schoenning(Uppsala University), S. Schumann(Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz), W. Shan(Peking University), M. Shao(University of Science and Technology of China), C. P. Shen(Beihang University), X. Y. Shen(COMSATS University Islamabad), H. Y. Sheng(COMSATS University Islamabad), M. R. Shepherd(Indiana University Bloomington), W. M. Song(COMSATS University Islamabad), X. Y. Song(COMSATS University Islamabad), S. Spataro(International University College of Turin), B. Spruck(COMSATS University Islamabad), G. X. Sun(COMSATS University Islamabad), J. F. Sun(Henan Normal University), S. S. Sun(COMSATS University Islamabad), Y. J. Sun(University of Science and Technology of China), Y. Z. Sun(University of Science and Technology of China), Z. J. Sun(University of Science and Technology of China), Z. T. Sun(University of Science and Technology of China), C. J. Tang(Sichuan University), X. Tang(COMSATS University Islamabad), İ. Tapan(Bursa Uludağ Üni̇versi̇tesi̇), E. H. Thorndike(University of Rochester), D. Toth(University of Minnesota), M. Ullrich(COMSATS University Islamabad), I. Uman(Doğuş University), G. S. Varner(University of Hawaiʻi at Mānoa), B. Wang(Nankai University), D. Wang(Peking University), D. Y. Wang(Peking University), K. Wang(COMSATS University Islamabad), L. L. Wang(COMSATS University Islamabad), L. S. Wang(COMSATS University Islamabad), M. Wang(Shandong University), P. Wang(COMSATS University Islamabad), P. L. Wang(COMSATS University Islamabad), Q. J. Wang(COMSATS University Islamabad), S. G. Wang(Peking University), W. Wang(Institute of High Energy Physics), X. F. Wang(Tsinghua University), Yaqian Wang(COMSATS University Islamabad), Y. F. Wang(COMSATS University Islamabad), Y. Q. Wang(Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz), Z. G. Wang(University of Science and Technology of China), Z. G. Wang(University of Science and Technology of China), Z. H. Wang(University of Science and Technology of China), Z. Y. Wang(University of Science and Technology of China), D. H. Wei(Guangxi Normal University), J. B. Wei(Peking University), P. Weidenkaff(Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz), S. P. Wen(COMSATS University Islamabad), M. Werner(COMSATS University Islamabad), U. Wiedner(Ruhr University Bochum), M. Wolke(Uppsala University), L. H. Wu(COMSATS University Islamabad), N. Wu(COMSATS University Islamabad), Z. Wu(COMSATS University Islamabad), L. G. Xia(Tsinghua University), Y. Xia(Hunan University), D. Xiao(COMSATS University Islamabad), Z. J. Xiao(Nanjing Normal University), Y. G. Xie(COMSATS University Islamabad), Q. L. Xiu(COMSATS University Islamabad), G. F. Xu(COMSATS University Islamabad), L. Xu(COMSATS University Islamabad), Q. Xu(Hangzhou Normal University), Q. N. Xu(Hangzhou Normal University), X. P. Xu(Soochow University), Z. Xue(COMSATS University Islamabad), L. Yan(University of Science and Technology of China), W. B. Yan(University of Science and Technology of China), W. C. Yan(University of Science and Technology of China), Y. H. Yan(Hunan University), H. X. Yang(COMSATS University Islamabad), Y. Yang(Guangxi Normal University), Y. Yang(Guangxi Normal University), H. Ye(COMSATS University Islamabad), M. H. Ye(Institute of High Energy Physics), M. H. Ye(Institute of High Energy Physics), B. X. Yu(COMSATS University Islamabad), C. X. Yu(Nankai University), H. W. Yu(Peking University), J. S. Yu(Lanzhou University), S. Yu(Shandong University), C. Z. Yuan(COMSATS University Islamabad), W. L. Yuan(Nanjing University), Y. Yuan(COMSATS University Islamabad), A. A. Zafar(University of the Punjab), A. Zallo(COMSATS University Islamabad), S. L. Zang(Nanjing University), Y. Zeng(Hunan University), B. X. Zhang(COMSATS University Islamabad), B. Y. Zhang(COMSATS University Islamabad), C. B. Zhang(Hunan University), C. B. Zhang(Hunan University), H. H. Zhang(COMSATS University Islamabad), D. H. Zhang(COMSATS University Islamabad), H. H. Zhang(Sun Yat-sen University), H. Y. Zhang(Sun Yat-sen University), J. J. Zhang(COMSATS University Islamabad), J. Q. Zhang(COMSATS University Islamabad), J. W. Zhang(COMSATS University Islamabad), J. Y. Zhang(COMSATS University Islamabad), Jiujun Zhang(COMSATS University Islamabad), S. H. Zhang(COMSATS University Islamabad), X. J. Zhang(Shandong University), X. Y. Zhang(Shandong University), Y. H. Zhang(COMSATS University Islamabad), Y. H. Zhang(COMSATS University Islamabad), Z. H. Zhang(University of Science and Technology of China), Z. P. Zhang(University of Science and Technology of China), Z. Y. Zhang(University of Science and Technology of China), G. Zhao(COMSATS University Islamabad), J. W. Zhao(COMSATS University Islamabad), Lei Zhao(University of Science and Technology of China), Ling Zhao(University of Science and Technology of China), M. G. Zhao(Nankai University), Q. Zhao(COMSATS University Islamabad), Q. W. Zhao(COMSATS University Islamabad), S. J. Zhao(Zhengzhou University), T. C. Zhao(COMSATS University Islamabad), X. Zhao(Nanjing University), Y. Zhao(COMSATS University Islamabad), Z. Zhao(University of Science and Technology of China), A. Zhemchugov(Joint Institute for Nuclear Research), B. Zheng(University of South China), J. P. Zheng(COMSATS University Islamabad), Y. H. Zheng(Chinese Academy of Sciences), B. Zhong(Nanjing Normal University), L. Zhou(Nankai University), Li Zhou(Nankai University), X. K. Zhou(University of Science and Technology of China), X. K. Zhou(University of Science and Technology of China), X. R. Zhou(University of Science and Technology of China), X. Y. Zhou(University of Science and Technology of China), K. J. Zhu(COMSATS University Islamabad), K. J. Zhu(COMSATS University Islamabad), Xiaoyu Zhu(Tsinghua University), Y. C. Zhu(University of Science and Technology of China), Y. S. Zhu(University of Science and Technology of China), Z. A. Zhu(COMSATS University Islamabad), J. Zhuang(COMSATS University Islamabad), B. S. Zou(COMSATS University Islamabad), J. H. Zou(COMSATS University Islamabad)
Physical Review Letters
March 3, 2014
Cited by 214Open Access
Full Text

Abstract

With data samples collected with the BESIII detector operating at the BEPCII storage ring at center-of-mass energies from 4.009 to 4.420 GeV, the process ${e}^{+}{e}^{\ensuremath{-}}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\gamma}X(3872)$ is observed for the first time with a statistical significance of $6.3\ensuremath{\sigma}$. The measured mass of the $X(3872)$ is $(3871.9\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.{7}_{\text{stat}}\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.{2}_{\text{syst}})\text{ }\text{ }\mathrm{MeV}/{c}^{2}$, in agreement with previous measurements. Measurements of the product of the cross section $\ensuremath{\sigma}[{e}^{+}{e}^{\ensuremath{-}}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\gamma}X(3872)]$ and the branching fraction $\mathcal{B}[X(3872)\ensuremath{\rightarrow}{\ensuremath{\pi}}^{+}{\ensuremath{\pi}}^{\ensuremath{-}}J/\ensuremath{\psi}]$ at center-of-mass energies 4.009, 4.229, 4.260, and 4.360 GeV are reported. Our measurements are consistent with expectations for the radiative transition process $Y(4260)\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\gamma}X(3872)$.


Related Papers

Review of Particle Physics
J. Beringer, J-F. Arguin, R. M. Barnett et al.|Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D, Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology|2012|6k
Design and construction of the BESIII detector
M. Ablikim, Z. H. An, J. Z. Bai et al.|Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A Accelerators Spectrometers Detectors and Associated Equipment|2010|1.2k
PHOTOS Monte Carlo: a precision tool for QED correctionsin Z and W decays
P. Golonka, Z. Was|The European Physical Journal C|2005|947
Coherent exclusive exponentiation for precision Monte Carlo calculations
S. Jadach, B. F. L. Ward, Z. Wa̧s|Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields|2001|821