Pheroze Tamboli

Renal cell carcinoma (RCC) is not a single disease, but several histologically defined cancers with different genetic drivers, clinical courses, and therapeutic responses. The current study evaluated 843 RCC from the three major histologic subtypes, including 488 clear cell RCC, 274 papillary RCC, and 81 chromophobe RCC. Comprehensive genomic and phenotypic analysis of the RCC subtypes reveals distinctive features of each subtype that provide the foundation for the development of subtype-specific therapeutic and management strategies for patients affected with these cancers. Somatic alteration of BAP1, PBRM1, and PTEN and altered metabolic pathways correlated with subtype-specific decreased survival, while CDKN2A alteration, increased DNA hypermethylation, and increases in the immune-related Th2 gene expression signature correlated with decreased survival within all major histologic subtypes. CIMP-RCC demonstrated an increased immune signature, and a uniform and distinct metabolic expression pattern identified a subset of metabolically divergent (MD) ChRCC that associated with extremely poor survival.

(Cell Reports 23, 313–326; April 3, 2018) In the originally published version of this article, the author list contained two errors. Specifically, David J. Kwiatkowski was misspelled as David J. Kwaitkowski, and William Y. Kim was inadvertently written as William T. Kim. Both names have been corrected online. The authors regret this error.

Just two and a half decades ago adult renal cell neoplasms, i.e., those arising from the renal tubules or collecting duct epithelium, were subdivided into two major subtypes: "clear cell carcinoma" and "granular cell carcinoma." Subsequent detailed morphologic and/or cytogenetic studies have resulted in the recognition of several distinctive subtypes of adult renal epithelial neoplasms, which has led to the promulgation of a refined contemporary histologic classification of these tumors. This study examines the prognostic significance of histologic subtyping in accordance with the new classification in a consecutive series of 405 cases treated at a single institution. Cases were histologically classified into 28 (7%) benign tumors [27 (6.7%) renal oncocytomas, 1 (0.2%) metanephric adenoma] and 377 (93%) malignant tumors [255 (63%) conventional (clear cell) renal cell carcinoma, 75 (18.5%) papillary renal cell carcinoma, 24 (5.9%) chromophobe renal cell carcinoma, and 23 (5.7%) renal cell carcinoma, unclassified]. A total of 25 (6.6%) malignant tumors showed evidence of sarcomatoid change. Kaplan-Meier survival analysis with log-rank test showed histologic type (p = 0.002), Fuhrman's nuclear grade (p = 0.001), TNM stage (p = 0.001), vascular invasion (p = 0.001), and necrosis (p = 0.001) to be significantly associated with disease-specific survival and progression-free survival, based on follow-up of 368 patients (mean 64.5 months, median 56 months). The 5-year disease-specific survival for chromophobe renal cell carcinoma, papillary renal cell carcinoma, conventional (clear cell) renal cell carcinoma, and renal cell carcinoma, unclassified was 100%, 86%, 76%, and 24%, respectively; no patient with a benign tumor diagnosis progressed or died of disease. The 5-year progression-free survival for chromophobe renal cell carcinoma, papillary renal cell carcinoma, conventional (clear cell) renal cell carcinoma, and renal cell carcinoma, unclassified was 94%, 88%, 70%, and 18%, respectively. Malignant tumors with sarcomatoid change had a 35% and 27%, 5-year disease-specific and progression-free survival, respectively. Cox proportional hazards regression analysis showed TNM stage (p = 0.001), nuclear grade (p = 0.01), and necrosis (p = 0.05) to be significant predictors of disease-specific survival. In conclusion, our study shows that the histologic categorization of adult renal epithelial neoplasms performed by routine light microscopic hematoxylin and eosin-based examination in accordance with the contemporary classification scheme has prognostic utility.

Sarcomatoid renal cell carcinoma is not a distinct histologic entity and represents high-grade transformation in different subtypes of renal cell carcinoma. It is not known whether any particular histologic type has a predilection for sarcomatoid change or whether the primary histologic type of renal carcinoma undergoing sarcomatoid change affects prognosis. Of 952 consecutively histologically subtyped renal cell carcinomas, the incidence of sarcomatoid differentiation was 8% in conventional (clear cell) renal carcinoma, 3% in papillary renal carcinoma, 9% in chromophobe renal carcinoma, 29% in collecting duct carcinoma, and 11% in unclassified renal cell carcinoma. One hundred one renal cell carcinomas with sarcomatoid change were studied, and clinicopathologic parameters were correlated with outcome. The mean age of patients was 60 years (range, 33-80 years), and the male-to-female ratio was 1.6:1. The median tumor size was 9.2 cm (range, 3-25 cm). The primary histologic subtype of the carcinoma component was conventional (clear cell) renal carcinoma in 80 cases, papillary renal carcinoma in eight, chromophobe renal carcinoma in seven, collecting duct carcinoma in two, and unclassified renal cell carcinoma in four. The sarcomatoid component resembled fibrosarcoma in 54 cases, malignant fibrous histiocytoma in 44, undifferentiated sarcoma (not otherwise specified) in three with focal rhabdomyosarcomatous component in two of them. The spindled elements accounted for 1% to 99% of the sampled tumor (median, 40%; mean 45%). The histologic grade of the spindled elements was intermediate to high in 92 cases and low in nine cases. Most cases were TNM stages III and IV (seven stage I, six stage II, 63 stage III, and 25 stage IV). Follow-up was available in 88 patients; 61 (69%) patients died of disease and had a median survival time of 19 months. Distant metastases, most frequently to the lungs, were documented in 51 (66%) of 77 patients who had available clinical information regarding distant metastasis. The disease-specific survival rate was 22% and 13% after 5 and 10 years, respectively, compared with a cohort of renal cell carcinomas without sarcomatoid change with a 5-and 10-year disease-specific survival of 79% and 76%, respectively. Kaplan-Meier survival analysis showed that tumors with high TNM stage (p = 0.0027), at least 50% sarcomatoid component (p = 0.0453), and angiolymphatic invasion (p = 0.0282) were associated with decreased survival rates. The primary histologic subtype of the carcinoma component and the type and grade of the sarcomatoid component did not affect survival. In a Cox proportional hazard regression model, TNM stage appeared to be the only significant variable in predicting outcome among renal cell carcinomas with sarcomatoid change (p = 0.018; risk ratio, 6.984 and 8.439). Compared with a cohort of renal cell carcinomas without sarcomatoid change, sarcomatoid tumors tended to present at a more advanced stage (p = 0.0001). Also, when adjusted for stage, necrosis, and tumor size, patients with tumors with sarcomatoid differentiation had a worse prognosis than did patients with tumors without sarcomatoid change (p = 0.0001). In conclusion, sarcomatoid change in renal cell carcinoma portends a worse prognosis. Because tumors with even a small component of sarcomatoid change may have an adverse outcome, this finding, when present, should be noted in the surgical pathology report.